John Wesley

A PLAIN ACCOUNT OF CHRISTIAN PERFECTION, AS BELIEVED AND TAUGHT BY
THE REVEREND MR. JOHN WESLEY,^ ^FROM THE YEAR 1725, TO THE YEAR 1777.

1.  What I purpose in the following papers is, to give a plain and
distinct account of the steps by which I was led, during a course of
many years, to embrace the doctrine of Christian perfection.  This I owe
to the serious part of mankind, those who desire to know all “the truth
as it is in Jesus.”  And these only are concerned in questions of this
kind.  To these I would nakedly declare the thing as it is, endeavouring
all along to show, from one period to another, both what I thought, and
why I thought so.

2.  In the year 1725, being in the twenty-third year of my age, I met
with Bishop Taylor’s “Rule and Exercises of Holy Living and Dying.”  In
reading several parts of this book, I was exceedingly affected; that
part in particular which relates to purity of intention.  Instantly I
resolved to dedicate all my life to God, all my thoughts, and words, and
actions; being thoroughly convinced, there was no medium; but that every
part of my life (not some only) must either be a sacrifice to God, or
myself, that is, in effect, to the devil.

Can any serious person doubt of this, or find a medium between serving
God and serving the devil?

3.  In the year 1726, I met with Kempis’s “Christian’s Pattern.”  The
nature and extent of inward religion, the religion of the heart, now
appeared to me in a stronger light than ever it had done before.  I saw,
that giving even all my life to God (supposing it possible to do this,
and go no farther would profit me nothing, unless I gave my heart, yea,
all my heart, to him.

I saw, that “simplicity of intention, and purity of affection,” one
design in all we speak or do, and one desire ruling all our tempers, are
indeed “the wings of the soul,” without which she can never ascend to
the mount of God.

4.  A year or two after, Mr.  Law’s “Christian Perfection” and “Serious
Call” were put into my hands.  These convinced me, more than ever, of
the absolute impossibility of being half a Christian; and I determined,
through his grace, (the absolute necessity of which I was deeply
sensible of;) to be all-devoted to God, to give him all my soul, my
body, and my substance

Will any considerate man say, that this is carrying matter too far?  or
that anything less is due to Him who has given himself for us, than to
give him ourselves, all we have, and all we are?

5.  In the year 1729, I began not only to read, but to study, the
Bible, as the one, the only standard of truth, and the only model of
pure religion.  Hence I saw, in a clearer and clearer light, the
indispensable necessity of having “the mind which was in Christ,” and of
“walking as Christ also walked;” even of having, not some part only, but
all the mind which was in him; and of walking as he walked, not only in
many or in most respects, but in all things.  And this was the light,
wherein at this time I generally considered religion, as an uniform
following of Christ, an entire inward and outward conformity to our
Master.  Nor was I afraid of anything more, than of bending this rule to
the experience of myself; or of other men; of allowing myself in any the
least disconformity to our grand Exemplar.

6.  On January 1, 1733, I preached before the University in St.  Mary’s
church, on “the Circumcision of the Heart;” an account of which I gave
in these words: “It is that habitual disposition of soul which, in the
sacred writings, is termed’ holiness; and which directly implies, the
being cleansed from sin `from all filthiness both of flesh and spirit;’
and, by consequence the being endued with those virtues which were in
Christ Jesus the being so `renewed in the image of our mind,’ as to be
`perfect as our Father in heaven is perfect.”‘  (Vol.  V., p.  203.)

In the same sermon I observed, “`Love is the fulfilling of the law, the
end of the commandment.’  It is not only `the first and great’ command,
but all the commandments in one.  `Whatsoever things are just,
whatsoever things are pure, if there be any virtue, if there be any
praise,’ they are all comprised in this one word, love.  In this is
perfection, and glory, and happiness: The royal law of heaven and earth
is this, `Thou shall love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with
all thy soul, and with all thy mind, and with all thy strength.’  The
one perfect good shall be your one ultimate end.  One thing shall ye
desire for its own sake, — the fruition of Him who is all in all.  One
happiness shall ye propose to your souls, even an union with Him that
made them, the having `fellowship with the Father and the Son,’ the
being `joined to the Lord in one spirit.’  One design ye are to pursue
to the end of time, — the enjoyment of God in time and in eternity.
Desire other things so far as they tend to this; love the creature, as
it leads to the Creator.  But in every step you take, be this the
glorious point that terminates your view.  Let every affection, and
thought and word, and action, be subordinate to this.  Whatever ye
desire or fear, whatever ye seek or shun, whatever ye think speak, or
do, be it in order to your happiness in God, the sole end, as well as
source, of your being.”  (+Ibid.+, pp.  207, 208.)

I concluded in these words: “Here is the sum of the perfect law, the
circumcision of the heart.  Let the spirit return to God that gave it,
with the whole train of its affections.  — Other sacrifices from us he
would not, but the living sacrifice of the heart hath he chosen.  Let it
be continually offered up to God through Christ, in flames of holy love.
And let no creature be suffered to share with him; for he is a jealous
God.  His throne will he not divide with another; he will reign without
a rival.  Be no design, no desire admitted there, but what has Him for
its ultimate object.  This is the way wherein those children of God once
walked, who being dead still speak to us: `Desire not to live but to
praise his name; let all your thoughts, words, and works tend to his
glory.’  `Let your soul be filled with so entire a love to Him that you
may love nothing but for his sake.’  `Have a pure intention of heart, a
steadfast regard to his glory in all you actions.’  For then, and not
till then, is that `mind in us, which was also in Christ Jesus,’ when in
every motion of our heart, in every word of our tongue, in every work of
our hands, we `pursue nothing but in relation to him, and in
subordination to his plea sure;’ when we too neither think, nor speak,
nor act, to fulfil `our own will, but the will of Him that sent us;’
when, `whether we eat or drink, or whatever we do,’ we do it all `to the
glory of God.”‘  (+Ibid.+, p.  211.)

It may be observed, this sermon was composed the first of all my
writings which have been published.  This was the view of religion I
then had, which even then I scrupled not to term +perfection.+ This is
the view I have of it now, without any material addition or diminution.
And what is there here, which any man of understanding, who believes the
Bible, can object to?  What can he deny, without flatly contradicting
the Scripture?  what retrench, without taking from the word of God?

7.  In the same sentiment did my brother and I remain (with all those
young gentlemen in derision termed +Methodists+) till we embarked for
America, in the latter end of 1735.  It was the next year, while I was
at Savannah, that I wrote the following lines: —

Is there a thing beneath the sun, That strives with thee my heart to
share?  Ah!  tear it thence, and reign alone, The Lord of every motion
there!

In the beginning of the year 1738, as I was returning from thence, the
cry of my heart was,

O grant that nothing in my soul May dwell, but thy pure love alone!  O
may thy love possess me whole, My joy, my treasure, and my crown !
Strange fires far from my heart remove; My every act, word, thought, be
love!

I never heard that any one objected to this.  And indeed who can
object?  Is not this the language, not only of every believer, but of
every one that is truly awakened?  But what have I wrote, to this day,
which is either stronger or plainer?

8.  In August following, I had a long conversation with Arvid Gradin,
in Germany.  After he had given me an account of his experience, I
desired him to give me, in writing, a definition of “the full assurance
of faith,” which he did in the following words: —

_Requies in sanguine Christi; firma fiducia in Deum, et persuasio de
gratia divina; tranquillitas mentis summa, atque serenitas et pax; cum
absentia omnis desiderii carnalis, et cessatione peccatorum etiam
internorum.

“Repose in the blood of Christ; a firm confidence in God, and
persuasion of his favour; the highest tranquillity, serenity, and peace
of mind, with a deliverance from every fleshly desire, and a cessation
of all, even inward sins.”

This was the first account I ever heard from any living man, of what I
had before learned myself from the oracles of God, and had been praying
for, (with the little company of my friends,) and expecting, for several
years.

9.  In 1739, my brother and I published a volume of “Hymns and Sacred
Poems.”  In many of these we declared our sentiments strongly and
explicitly.  So, page 24, —

Turn the fall stream of nature’s tide; Let all our actions tend To
thee, their source; thy love the guide, Thy glory be the end.

Earth then a scale to heaven shall be; Sense shall point out the road;
The creatures all shall lead to thee, And all we taste be God.

Again, —

Lord, arm me with thy Spirit’s might, Since I am call’d by thy great
name: In thee my wand’ring thoughts unite, Of all my works be thou the
aim: Thy love attend me all my days, And my sole business be thy praise.
(Page 122.)

Again, —

Eager for thee I ask and pant, So strong the principle divine, Carries
me out with sweet constraint, Till all my hallow’d soul be thine;
Plunged in the Godhead’s deepest sea, And lost in thine immensity!
(Page 125.)

Once more, —

Heavenly Adam, life divine, Change my nature into thine; Move and
spread throughout my soul, Actuate and fill the whole.  (Page 153.)

It would be easy to cite many more passages to the same effect.  But
these are sufficient to show, beyond contradiction, what our sentiments
then were.

10.  The first tract I ever wrote expressly on this subject was
published in the latter end of this year.  That none might be prejudiced
before they read it, I gave it the indifferent title of “The Character
of a Methodist.”  In this I described a perfect Christian, placing in
the front, “Not as though I had already attained.”  Part of it I subjoin
without any alteration: —

“A Methodist is one who loves the Lord his God with all his heart, with
all his soul, with all his mind, and with all his strength.  God is the
joy of his heart, and the desire of his soul, which is continually
crying, `Whom have I in heaven but thee?  and there is none upon earth
whom I desire besides thee.’  My God and my all!  `Thou art the strength
of my heart, and my portion for ever.’  He is therefore happy in God;
yea, always happy, as having in him a well of water springing up unto
everlasting life, and over-flowing his soul with peace and joy.  Perfect
love living now cast out fear, he rejoices evermore.  Yea, his joy is
full, and all his bones cry out, `Blessed be the God and Father of our
Lord Jesus Christ, who, according to his abundant mercy, hath begotten
me again unto a living hope of an inheritance incorruptible and
undefiled, reserved in heaven for me.’

“And he, who hath this hope, thus full of immortality, in everything
giveth thanks, as knowing this (whatsoever it is) is the will of God in
Christ Jesus concerning him.  From him therefore he cheerfully receives
all, saying, `Good is the will of the Lord;’ and whether he giveth or
taketh away, equally blessing the name of the Lord.  Whether in ease or
pain, whether in sickness or health, whether in life or death, he giveth
thanks from the ground of the heart to Him who orders it for good; into
whose hands he hath wholly committed his body and soul, `as into the
hands of a faithful Creator.’  He is therefore anxiously `careful for
nothing,’ as having `cast all his care on Him that careth for him;’ and
`in all things’ resting on him, after `making’ his `request known to him
with thanksgiving.’

“For indeed he `prays without ceasing;’ at all times the language of
his heart is this, `Unto thee is my mouth, though without a voice; and
my silence speaketh unto thee.’  His heart is lifted up to God at all
times, and in all places.  In this he is never hindered, much less
interrupted, by any person or thing.  In retirement or company, in
leisure, business, or conversation, his heart is ever with the Lord.
Whether he lie down, or rise up, `God is in all his thoughts:’ He walks
with God continually; having the loving eye of his soul fixed on him,
and everywhere `seeing Him that is invisible.’

“And loving God, he `loves his neighbour as himself;’ he loves every
man as his own soul.  He loves his enemies, yea, and the enemies of God.
And if it be not in his power to `do good to them that hate’ him, yet he
ceases not to `pray for them,’ though they spurn his love, and still
`despite.  fully use him, and persecute him.’

“For he is `pure in heart.’  Love has purified his heart from envy,
malice, wrath, and every unkind temper.  It has cleansed him from pride,
whereof `only cometh contention;’ and he hath now `put on bowels of
mercies, kindness, humbleness of mind, meekness, long-suffering.’  And
indeed all possible ground for contention, on his part, is cut off.  For
none can take from him what he desires, seeing he `loves not the world,
nor any of the things of the world;’ but `all his desire is unto God,
and to the remembrance of his name.’

“Agreeable to this his one desire, is this one design of his life;
namely, `to do, not his own will, but the will of Him that sent him.’
His one intention at all times and in all places is, not to please
himself, but Him whom his soul loveth.  He hath a single eye; and
because his `eye is single, his whole body is full of light.  The whole
is light, as when the bright shining of a candle doth enlighten the
house.’  God reigns alone; all that is in the soul is `holiness to the
Lord.’  There is not a motion in his heart but is according to his will.
Every thought that arises points to him, and is in `obedience to the law
of Christ.’

“And the tree is known by its fruits.  For, as he loves God, so he
`keeps his commandments;’ not only some, or most of them, but all, from
the least to the greatest.  He is not content to `keep the whole law and
offend in one point,’ but has iii all points `a conscience void of
offence towards God, and towards man.’  Whatever God has forbidden, he
avoids; whatever God has enjoined, he does.  `He runs the way of God’s
commandments,’ now He bath set his heart at liberty.  It is his glory
and joy so to do; it is his daily crown of rejoicing, to `do the will of
God on earth, as it is done in heaven.’

“All the commandments of God he accordingly keeps, and that with all
his might; for his obedience is in proportion to his love, the source
from whence it flows.  And therefore, loving God with all his heart, he
serves him with all his strength; he continually presents his soul and
`body a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable to God;’ entirely and without
reserve devoting himself, all he has, all he is, to his glory.  All the
talents he has, he constantly employs according to his Master’s will;
every power and faculty of his soul, every member of his body.

“By consequence, `whatsoever he doeth, it is all to the glory of God.’
In all his employments of every kind, he not only aims at this, which is
implied in having a single eye, but actually attains it; his business
and his refreshments, as well as his prayers, all serve to this great
end.  Whether he `sit in the house, or walk by the way,’ whether he lie
down, or rise up, he is promoting, in all he speaks or does, the one
business of his life.  Whether he put on his apparel, or labour, or eat
and drink, or divert himself from too wasting labour, it all tends to
advance the glory of God, by peace and good-will among men.  His one
invariable rule is this: `Whatsoever ye do, in word or deed, do it all
in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God, even the Father,
through him.’

“Nor do the customs of the world at all hinder his ` running the race
which is set before him.’  He cannot therefore `lay up treasures upon
earth,’ no more than he can take fire into his bosom.  He cannot speak
evil of his neighbour, any more than he can lie either for God or man.
He cannot utter an unkind word of any one; for love keeps the door of
his lips.  He cannot `speak idle words; no corrupt conversation’ ever
`comes out of his mouth;’ as is all that is not `good to the use of
edifying,’ not fit to `minister grace to the hearers.’  But `whatsoever
things are pure, whatsoever things are lovely, whatsoever things are’
justly `of good report,’ he thinks, speaks, and acts, `adorning the
doctrine of God our Saviour in all things.'”

These are the very words wherein I largely declared, for the first
time, my sentiments of Christian perfection.  And is it not easy to see,
(1.)  That this is the very point at which I aimed all along from the
year 1725; and more determinately from the year 1730, when I began to be
+homo unius libri,+ “a man of one book,” regarding none, comparatively,
but the Bible?  Is it not easy to see, (2.)  That this is the very same
doctrine which I believe and teach at this day; not adding one point,
either to that inward or outward holiness which I maintained eight-and-
thirty years ago?  And it is the same which, by the grace of God, I have
continued to teach from that time till now; as will appear to every
impartial person from the extracts subjoined below.

11.  I do not know that any writer has made any objection against that
tract to this day; and for some time, I did not find much opposition
upon the head, at least, not from serious persons.  But after a time, a
cry arose, and, what a little surprised me, among religions men, who
affirmed, not that I stated perfection wrong, but that “there is no
perfection on earth;” nay, and fell vehemently on my brother and me for
affirming the contrary.  We scarce expected so rough an attack from
these; especially as we were clear on justification by faith, and
careful to ascribe the whole of salvation to the mere grace of God.  But
what most surprised us, was, that we were said to “dishonour Christ,” by
asserting that he “saveth to the uttermost;” by maintaining he will
reign in our hearts alone, and subdue all things to himself.

12.  I think it was in the latter end of the year 1740, that I had a
conversation with Dr.  Gibson, then Bishop of London, at Whitehall.  He
asked me what I meant by perfection.  I told him without any disguise or
reserve.  When I ceased speaking, he said, “Mr.  Wesley, if this be all
you mean, publish it to all the world.  If any one then can confute what
you say, lie may have free leave.”  I answered, “My Lord, I will;” and
accordingly wrote and published the sermon on Christian perfection.

In this I endeavoured to show, (1.)  In what sense Christians are not,
(2.)  In what sense they are, perfect.

“(1.)  In what sense they are not.  They are not perfect in knowledge.
They are not free from ignorance, no, nor from mistake.  We are no more
to expect any living man to be infallible, than to be omniscient.  They
are not free from infirmities, such as weakness or slowness of
understanding, irregular quickness or heaviness of imagination.  Such in
another kind are impropriety of language, ungracefulness of
pronunciation; to which one- might add a thousand nameless defects,
either in conversation or behaviour.  From such infirmities as these
none are perfectly freed till their spirits return to God; neither can
we expect till then to be wholly freed from temptation; for `the servant
is not above his master.’  But neither in this sense is there any
absolute perfection on earth.  There is no perfection of degrees, none
which does not admit of a continual increase.

“(2.)  In what sense then are they perfect?  Observe, we are not now
speaking of babes in Christ, but adult Christians But even babes in
Christ are so far perfect as not to commit sin.  This St.  John affirms
expressly; and it cannot be disproved by the examples of the Old
Testament.  For what, if the holiest of the ancient Jews did sometimes
commit sin?  We cannot infer from hence, that `all Christians do and
must commit sin as long as they live.’

“But does not the Scripture say, `A just man sinneth seven times a
day?’  It does not.  Indeed it says, `A just man falleth seven times.’
But this is quite another thing; for, First, the words, a day, are not
in the text.  Secondly, here is no mention of falling into sin at all.
What is here mentioned, is, falling into temporal affliction.

“But elsewhere Solomon says, `There is no man that sinneth not.’
Doubtless thus it was in the days of Solomon; yea, and from Solomon to
Christ there was then no man that sinned not.  But whatever was the case
of those under the law, we may safely affirm, with St.  John, that,
since the gospel was given, `lie that is born of God sinneth not.’

“The privileges of Christians are in nowise to be measured by what the
Old Testament records concerning those who were under the Jewish
dispensation; seeing the fulness of time is now come, the Holy Ghost is
now given, the great salvation of God is now brought to men by the
revelation of Jesus Christ.  The kingdom of heaven is now set up on
earth, concerning which the Spirit of God declared of old time, (so far
is David from being the pattern or standard of Christian perfection,)
`He that is feeble among them, at that day, shall be as David, and the
house of David shall be as the angel of the Lord before them.’  (Zech.
12:8.)

“But the Apostles themselves committed sin; Peter by dissembling, Paul
by his sharp contention with Barnabas.  Suppose they did, will you argue
thus: `If two of the Apostles once committed sin, then all other
Christians, in all ages, do and must commit sin as long as they live ?’
Nay, God forbid we should thus speak.  No necessity of sin was laid upon
them; the grace of God was surely sufficient for them.  And it is
sufficient for us at this day.

“But St.  James says, `In many things we offend all.’  True; but who
are the persons here spoken of?  Why, those `many masters’ or teachers
whom God had not sent; not the Apostle himself, nor any real Christian.
That in the word we, used by a figure of speech, common in all other as
well as the inspired writings, the Apostle could not possibly include
himself, or any other true believer, appears, First, from the ninth
verse, `Therewith bless we God, and therewith curse we men.’  Surely not
we Apostles!  not we believers!  Secondly, from the words preceding the
text: `My brethren, be not many masters,’ or teachers, `knowing that we
shall receive the greater condemnation.  For in many things we offend
all.’  +We!+ Who?  Not the Apostles nor true believers, but they who
were to `receive the greater condemnation,’ because of those many
offences.  Nay, Thirdly, the verse itself proves, that `we offend all,’
cannot be spoken either of all men or all Christians.  For in it
immediately follows the mention of a man who `offends not,’ as the +we+
first mentioned did; from whom therefore he is professedly
contradistinguished, and pronounced a `perfect man.’

“But St.  John himself says, `If we say that we have no sin, we deceive
ourselves;’ and, `If we say we have not sinned, we make him a liar, and
his word is not in us.’

“I answer, (1.)  The tenth verse fixes the sense of the eighth: `If we
say we have no sin,’ in the former, being explained by, `If we say we
have not sinned,’ in the latter, verse.  (2.)  The point under
consideration is not, whether we have or have not sinned heretofore; and
neither of these verses asserts that we do sin, or commit sin now.  (3.)
The ninth verse explains both the eighth and tenth: `If we confess our
sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us
from all unrighteousness.’  As if he had said, `I have before affirmed,
The blood of Christ cleanseth from all sin.’  And no man can say, `I
need it not; I have 110 sin to be cleansed, from.’  `If we say, we have
no sin, that `we have not sinned, we deceive ourselves,’ and make God a
liar: But `if we confess our sins, he is faithful and just,’ not only
`to forgive us our sins,’ but also `to cleanse us from all
unrighteousness,’ that we may `go and sin no more.’  In conformity,
therefore, both to the doctrine of St.  John, and the whole tenor of the
New Testament, we fix this conclusion: A Christian is so far perfect, as
not to commit sin.

“This is the glorious privilege of every Christian, yea, though he be
but a babe in Christ.  But it is only of grown Christians it can be
affirmed, they are in such a sense perfect, as, Secondly, to be freed
from evil thoughts and evil tempers.  First, from evil or sinful
thoughts.  Indeed, whence should they spring?  `Out of the heart of
man,’ if at all, `proceed evil thoughts.’  If, therefore, the heart be
no longer evil, then evil thoughts no longer proceed out of it: For `a
good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit.’

“And as they are freed from evil thoughts, so likewise from evil
tempers.  Every one of these can say, with St.  Paul, `I am crucified
with Christ; nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me;’ –
– words that manifestly describe a deliverance from inward as well as
from outward sin.  This is expressed both negatively, `I live not,’ my
evil nature, the body of sin, is destroyed; and positively, `Christ
liveth in me,’ and therefore all that is holy, and just, and good.
Indeed, both these, `Christ liveth in me,’ and, `I live not,’ are
inseparably connected.  For what communion hath light with darkness, or
Christ with Belial?

“He, therefore, who liveth in these Christians hath `purified their
hearts by faith;’ insomuch that every one that has Christ in him, `the
hope of glory, purifieth himself even as he is pure.’  He is purified
from pride; for Christ was lowly in heart: He is pure from desire and
self-will; for Christ desired only to do the will of his Father: And he
is pure from anger, in the common sense of the word; for Christ `was
meek and gentle.  I say, +in the common sense of the word;+ for he is
angry at sin, while he is grieved for the sinner.  He feels a
displacency at every offence against God, but only tender compassion to
the offender.

“Thus doth Jesus save his people from their sins, not only from outward
sins, but from the sins of their hearts.  `True,’ say some, `but not
till death, not in this world.’  Nay, St.  John says, `Herein is our
love made perfect, that we may have boldness in the day of judgment;
because, as he is, so are we in this world.’  The Apostle here, beyond
all contradiction, speaks of himself and other living Christians, of
whom he flatly affirms, that, not only at or after death, but ` in this
world,’ they are `as their Master.’

“Exactly agreeable to this are his words in the first chapter: `God is
light, and in him is no darkness at all.  If we walk in the light, as he
is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of
Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all sin.’  And again: `If we
confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to
cleanse us from all unrighteousness.’  Now, it is evident, the Apostle
here speaks of a deliverance wrought in this world: For he saith not,
The blood of Christ will cleanse, (at the hour of death, or in the day
of judgment,) but it `cleanseth,’ at the time present, us living
Christians `from all sin.’  And it is equally evident, that if any sin
remain, we are not cleansed from `all’ sin.  If any unrighteousness
remain in the soul, it is not cleansed from `all, unrighteousness.
Neither let any say that this relates to justification only, or the
cleansing us from the guilt of sin: First, because this is confounding
together what the Apostle clearly distinguishes, who mentions, first,
`to forgive us our sins, and then `to cleanse us from all
unrighteousness.’  Secondly, because this is asserting justification by
works, in the strongest sense possible; it is making all inward, as well
as all outward, holiness, necessarily previous to justification.  For if
the cleansing here spoken of is no other than the cleansing us from the
guilt of sin, then we are not cleansed from guilt, that is, not
justified, unless on condition of walking `in the light, as he is in the
light.’  It remains, then, that Christians are saved in this world from
all sin, from all unrighteousness; that they are now in such a sense
perfect, as not to commit sin, and to be freed from evil thoughts and
evil tempers.”

It could not be, but that a discourse of this kind, which directly
contradicted the favourite opinion of many, who were~ esteemed by
others, and possibly esteemed themselves, some of the best of
Christians, (whereas, if these things were so, they were not Christians
at all,) should give no small offence.  Many answers or animadversions,
therefore, were expected; but I was agreeably disappointed.  I do not
know that any appeared; so I went quietly on my way.

13.  Not long after, I think in the spring, 1741, we published a second
volume of Hymns.  As the doctrine was still much misunderstood, and
consequently misrepresented, I judged it needful to explain yet farther
upon the head; which was done in the preface to it as follows : —

“This great gift of God, the salvation of our souls, is no other than
the image of God fresh stamped on our hearts.  It is a `renewal of
believers in the spirit of their minds, after the likeness of Him that
created them.’  God hath now laid `the axe unto the root of the tree,
purifying their hearts by faith,’ and `cleansing all the thoughts of
their hearts by the inspiration of his Holy Spirit.’  Having this hope,
that they shall see God as he is, they `purify themselves even as he is
pure,’ and are `holy, as he that hath called them is holy, in all manner
of conversation.’  Not that they have already attained all that they
shall attain, either are already in this sense perfect.  But they daily
`go on from strength to strength; beholding’ now, `as in a glass, the
glory of the Lord, they are changed into the same image, from glory to
glory, by the Spirit of the Lord.’

“And `where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty;’ such liberty
`from the law of sin and death,’ as the children of this world will not
believe, though a man declare it unto them.  `The Son hath made them
free’ who are thus `born of God,’ from that great root of sin and
bitterness, pride.  They feel that all their `sufficiency is of God,’
that it is He alone who `is in all their thoughts,’ and ` worketh in
them both to will and to do of his good pleasure.’  They feel that `it
is not they’ that `speak, but the Spirit of’ their `Father who speaketh’
in them, and that whatsoever is done by their hands, ` the Father who is
in them, he doeth the works.’  So that God is to them all in all, and
they are nothing in his sight.  They are freed from self-will, as
desiring nothing but the holy and perfect will of God; not supplies in
want, not ease in pain, [This is too strong.  Our Lord himself desired
ease in pain.’  He asked’ for it, only with resignation: “Not as I
will,” I desire, “but as thou wilt.”] nor life, or death, or any
creature; but continually crying in their Inmost soul, `Father, thy will
be done.’  They are freed from evil thoughts, so that they cannot enter
into them, no, not for a moment.  Aforetime, when an evil thought came
in, they hooked up, and it vanished away.  But now it does not come in,
there being no room for this, in a soul which is full of God.  They are
free from wanderings in prayer.  Whensoever they pour out their hearts
in a more immediate manner before God, they have no thought of anything
past, [This is far too strong.  See the sermon “On Wandering Thoughts.”]
or absent, or to come, but of God alone.  In times past, they had
wandering thoughts darted in, which yet fled away hike smoke; but now
that smoke does not rise at all.  They have no fear or doubt, either as
to their state in genera], or as to any particular action.  [Frequently
this is the case; but only for a time.] The `unction from the Holy One’
teacheth them every hour what they shall do, and what they shall speak;
[For a time it may be so; but not always.] nor therefore have they any
need to reason concerning it.  [Sometimes they have no need; at other
times they have.] They are in one sense freed from temptations; for
though numberless temptations fly about them, yet they trouble them not.
[Sometimes they do not; at other times they do, and that grievously.] At
all times their souls are even and calm, their hearts are steadfast and
unmovable.  Their peace, flowing as a river, `passeth all
understanding,’ and they `rejoice with joy unspeakable and full of
glory.’  For they `are sealed by the Spirit unto the day of redemption,’
having the witness in themselves, that `there is laid up for’ them a
`crown of righteousness~ which the Lord will give’ them `in that day.’
[Not all who are saved from sin; many of them have not attained it yet.]

“Not that every one is a child of the devil, till he is thus renewed in
love: On the contrary, whoever has a sure confidence in God, that
through the merits of Christ, his sins are forgiven,’ he is a child of
God, and, if he abide in him, an heir of all the promises.  Neither
ought he in anywise to cast away his confidence, or to deny the faith he
has received, because it is weak, or because it is tried with fire,’ so
that his soul is `in heaviness through manifold temptations.’

~~”Neither dare we affirm, as some have done, that all this salvation
is given at once.  There is indeed an instantaneous, as well as a
gradual, work of God in his children; and there wants not, we know, a
cloud of witnesses, who have received, in one moment, either a clear
sense of the forgiveness of their sins, or the abiding witness of the
Holy Spirit.  But we do not know a single instance, in any place, of a
person’s receiving, in one and the same moment, remission of sins, the
abiding witness of the Spirit, and a new, a clean heart.

“Indeed, how God may work, we cannot tell; but the general manner
wherein he does work is this: Those who once trusted in themselves that
they were righteous, that they were rich, and increased in goods, and
had need of nothing, are, by the Spirit of God applying his word,
convinced that they are poor and naked.  All the things that they have
done are brought to their remembrance and set in array before them, so
that they see the wrath of God hanging over their heads, and feel that
they deserve the damnation of hell.  In their trouble they cry unto the
Lord, and he shows them.  that he hath taken away their sins, and opens
the kingdom of heaven in their hearts, righteousness, and peace, and joy
in the Holy Ghost.’  Sorrow and pain are fled away, and sin has no more
dominion over’ them.  Knowing they are justified freely through faith in
his blood, they have peace with God * + through Jesus Christ;’ they
`rejoice in hope of the glory of God,’ and `the love of God is shed
abroad in their hearts.’

“In this peace they remain for days, or weeks, or months, and commonly
suppose they shall not know war any more; till some of their old
enemies, their bosom sins, or the sin which did most easily beset them,
(perhaps anger or desire,) assault them again, and thrust sore at them,
that they may fall.  Then arises fear, that they shall not endure to the
end; and often doubt, whether God has not forgotten them, or whether
they did not deceive themselves in thinking their sins were forgiven.
Under these clouds, especially if they reason with the devil, they go
mourning all the day long.  But it is seldom long before their Lord
answers for himself, sending them the Holy Ghost to comfort them, to
bear witness continually with their spirits that they are’ the children
of God.  Then they are indeed meek and gentle and teachable, even as a
little child.  And now first do they see the ground of their heart; [Is
it not astonishing, that while this book is extant, which was published
four-and-twenty years ago, any one should face me down, that this is a
new doctrine, and what I never taught before?  — [This note was first
published in the year 1765 EDIT.]] which God before would not disclose
unto them, lest the soul should fail before him, and the spirit which he
had made.  Now they see all the hidden abominations there, the depths of
pride, self-will, and hell; yet leaving the witness in themselves, `Thou
art an heir of God, a joint heir with Christ, even in the midst of this
fiery trial;’ which continually heightens both the strong sense they
then have of their inability to help themselves, and the inexpressible
hunger they feel after a full renewal in his image, in `righteousness
and true holiness.’  Then God is mindful of the desire of them that fear
him, and gives them a single eye, and a pure heart; he stamps upon them
his own image and superscription; He createth them anew in Christ Jesus;
he cometh unto them with his Son and blessed Spirit, and, fixing his
abode in their souls, bringeth them into the `rest which remaineth for
the people of God.'”

Here I cannot but remark, (1.)  That this is the strongest account we
ever gave of Christian perfection; indeed too strong in more than one
particular, as is observed in the notes annexed.  (2.)  That there is
nothing which we have since advanced upon the subject, either in verse
or prose, which is not either directly or indirectly contained in this
preface.  So that whether our present doctrine be right or wrong, it is
however the same which we taught from the beginning.

14.  I need not give additional proofs of this, by multiplying
quotations from the volume itself.  It may suffice, to cite part of one
hymn only the last in that volume: —

Lord, I believe a rest remains, To all thy people known; A rest where
pure enjoyment reigns, And thou art loved alone;

A rest where all our soul’s desire Is fix’d on things above; Where
doubt and pain and fear expire, Cast out by perfect love.

From every evil motion freed, (The Son hath made us free,) On all the
powers of hell we tread, In glorious liberty.

Safe in the way of life, above Death, earth, and hell we rise; We find,
when perfected in love, Our long-sought paradise.

O that I now the rest might know, Believe, and enter in!  Now, Saviour,
now the power bestow, And let me cease from sin!

Remove this hardness from my heart, This unbelief remove: To me the
rest of faith impart, The sabbath of thy love.

Come, O my Saviour, come away Into my soul descend!  No longer from thy
creature stay, My author and my end.

The bliss thou hast for me prepared, No longer be delay’d: Come, my
exceeding great reward, For whom I first was made.

Come, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, And seal me thine abode!  Let all I
am in thee be lost: Let all be lost in God!

Can anything be more clear, than, (1.)  That here also is as full and
high a salvation as we have ever spoken of?  (2.)  That this is spoken
of as receivable by mere faith, and as hindered only by unbelief?  (3.)
That this faith, and consequently the salvation which it brings, is
spoken of as given in aninstant?  (4.)  That it is supposed that instant
may be now?  that we need not stay another moment?  that “now,” the very
“now, is the accepted time?  now is the day of” this full “salvation?”
And, Lastly, that, if any speak otherwise, he is the person that brings
new doctrine among us?

15.  About a year after, namely, in the year 1742, we published another
volume of Hymns.  The dispute being now at the height, we spoke upon the
head more largely than ever before.  Accordingly abundance of the hymns
in this volume treat expressly on this subject.  And so does the
preface, which, as it is short, it may not be amiss to insert entire : –
–

“(1.)  Perhaps the general prejudice against Christian perfection may
chiefly arise from a misapprehension of the nature of it.  We willingly
allow, and continually declare, there is no such perfection in this
life, as implies either a dispensation from doing good, and attending
all the ordinances of God, or a freedom from ignorance, mistake,
temptation, and a thousand infirmities necessarily connected with flesh
and blood.

“(2.)  First.  We not only allow, but earnestly contend, that there is
no perfection in this life, which implies any dispensation from
attending all the ordinances of God, or from doing good unto all men
while we have time, though `especially unto the household of faith.’  We
believe, that not only the babes in Christ, who have newly found
redemption in his blood, but those also who are `grown up into perfect
men,’ are indispensably obliged, as often as they have opportunity, `to
eat bread and drink wine in remembrance of Him,’ and to `search the
Scriptures;’ by fasting, as well as temperance, to `keep their bodies
under, and bring them into subjection;’ and, above all, to pour out
their souls in prayer, both secretly, and in the great congregation.

“(3.)  We Secondly believe, that there is no such perfection in this
life, as implies an entire deliverance, either from ignorance, or
mistake, in things not essential to salvation, or from manifold
temptations, or from numberless infirmities, wherewith the corruptible
body more or less presses down the soul.  We cannot find any ground in
Scripture to suppose, that any inhabitant of a house of clay is wholly
exempt either from bodily infirmities, or from ignorance of many things;
or to imagine any is incapable of mistake, or falling into divers
temptations.

“(4.)  But whom then do you mean by `one that is perfect?’  We mean one
in whom is `the mind which was in Christ,’ and who so `walketh as Christ
also walked;’ a man `that hath clean hands and a pure heart,’ or that is
`cleansed from all filthiness of flesh and spirit;’ one in whom is `no
occasion of stumbling,’ and who, accordingly, `does not commit sin.’  To
declare this a little more particularly: We understand by that
scriptural expression, `a perfect man,’ one in whom God hath fulfilled
his faithful word, `From all your filthiness and from all your idols I
will cleanse you: I will also save you from all your uncleannesses.’  We
understand hereby, one whom God lath `sanctified throughout in body,
soul, and spirit;’ one who `walketh in the light as He is in the light,
in whom is no darkness at all; the blood of Jesus Christ his Son having
cleansed him from all sin.’

“(5.)  This man can now testify to all mankind, `I am crucified with
Christ: Nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me.’  He is
`holy as God who called’ him `is holy,’ both in heart and `in all manner
of conversation.’  He `loveth the Lord his God with all his heart,’ and
serveth him `with all his strength.’  He `loveth his neighbour,’ every
man, `as himself;’ yea, `as Christ loveth us;’ them, in particular, that
`despitefully use him and persecute him, because they know not the Son,
neither the Father.’  Indeed his soul is all love, filled with `bowels
of mercies, kindness, meekness, gentleness, longsuffering.’  And his
life agreeth thereto, full of `the work of faith, the patience of hope,
the labour of love.’  `And whatsoever’ he `doeth either in word or
deed,’ he `doeth it all in the name,’ in the love and power, `of the
Lord Jesus.’  In a word, he doeth `the will of God on earth, as it is
done in heaven.’

“(6.)  This it is to be a perfect man, to be `sanctified throughout;’
even `to have a heart so all-flaming with the love of God,’ (to use
Archbishop Usher’s words,) `as continually to offer up every thought,
word, and work, as a spiritual sacrifice, acceptable to God through
Christ.’  In every thought of our hearts, in every word of our tongues,
in every work of our hands, to `show forth his praise, who bath called
us out of darkness into his marvellous light.’  O that both we, and all
who seek the Lord Jesus in sincerity, may thus `be made perfect in
one!'”

This is the doctrine which we preached from the beginning, and which we
preach at this day.  Indeed, by viewing it in every point of light, and
comparing it again and again with the word of God on the one hand, and
the experience of the children of God on the other, we saw farther into
the nature and properties of Christian perfection.  But still there is
no contrariety at all between our first and our last sentiments.  Our
first conception of it was, It is to have “the mind which was in
Christ,” and to “walk as He walked;” to have all the mind that was in
Him, and always to walk as he walked: In other words, to be inwardly and
outwardly devoted to God; all devoted in heart and life.  And we have
the same conception of it now, without either addition or diminution.

16.  The hymns concerning it in this volume are too numerous to
transcribe.  I shall only cite a part of three : —

Saviour from sin, I wait to prove That Jesus is thy healing name; To
lose, when perfected in love, Whate’er I have, or can, or am; I stay me
on thy faithful word, “The servant shall be as his Lord.”

Answer that gracious end in me For which thy precious life was given;
Redeem from all iniquity, Restore, and make me meet for heaven.  Unless
thou purge my every stain, Thy suffering and my faith is vain.

Didst thou not die, that I might live, No longer to myself but thee?
Might body, soul, and spirit give To Him who gave himself for me?  Come
then, my Master and my God, Take the dear purchase of thy blood.

Thy own peculiar servant claim, For thy own truth and mercy’s sake;
Hallow in me thy glorious name; Me for thine own this moment take; And
change and throughly purify; Thine only may I live and die.  (Page 80.)

Chose from the world, if now I stand, Adorn’d with righteousness
divine; If, brought into the promised land, I justly call the Saviour
mine;

The sanctifying Spirit pour, To quench my thirst and wash me clean,
Now, Saviour let the gracious shower Descend, and make me pure from sin.

Purge me from every sinful blot: My idols all be cast aside: Cleanse me
from every evil thought, From all the filth of self and pride.

The hatred of the carnal mind Out of my flesh at once remove: Give me a
tender heart, resign’d, And pure, and fall of faith and love.

O that I now, from sin released, Thy word might to the utmost prove,
Enter into thy promised rest; The Canaan of thy perfect love!

Now let me gain perfection’s height!  Now let me into nothing fall; Be
less than nothing in my sight, And feel that Christ is all in all.
(Page 258.)

Lord, I believe, thy work of grace Is perfect in the soul; His heart is
pure who sees thy face, His spirit is made whole.

From every sickness, by thy word, From every foul disease, Saved, and
to perfect health restored, To perfect holiness:

He walks in glorious liberty, To sin entirely dead: The Truth, the Son
hath made him free, And he is free indeed.

Throughout his soul thy glories shine, His soul is all renew’d, And
deck’d in righteousness divine, And clothed and fill’d with God.

This is the rest, the life, the peace, Which all thy people prove; Love
is the bond of perfectness, And all their soul is love.

O joyful sound of gospel grace!  Christ shall in me appear; I, even I,
shall see his face, I shall be holy here!

He visits now the house of clay, He shakes his future home; — O
would’st thou, Lord, on this glad day, Into thy temple come!

Come, O my God, thyself reveal, Fill all this mighty void; Thou only
canst my spirit fill: Come, O my God, my God!

Fulfil, falfil my large desires, Large as infinity!  Give, give me all
my soul requires, All, all that is in thee ! (Page 298.)

17.  On Monday, June 25, 1744, our First Conference began; six
Clergymen and all our Preachers being present.  The next morning we
seriously considered the doctrine of sanctification, or perfection.  The
questions asked concerning it, and the substance of the answers given,
were as follows: —

“QUESTION. What is it to be sanctified?

“ANSWER. To be renewed in the image of God, `in righteousness and true
holiness.’

“Q. What is implied in being a perfect Christian?

“A. The loving God with all our heart, and mind, and soul.  (Deut.
6:5.)

“Q. Does this imply, that all inward sin is taken away?

“A. Undoubtedly; or how can we be Said to be `saved from all `our
uncleannesses?’  (Ezek.  36:29.)”

Our Second Conference began August 1, 1745.  The next morning we spoke
of sanctification as follows : —

“Q. When does inward sanctification begin?

“A. In the moment a man is justified.  (Yet sin remains in him, yea,
the seed of all sin, till he is sanctified throughout.)  From that time
a believer gradually dies to sin, and grows in grace.

“Q. Is this ordinarily given till a little before death?

“A. It is not, to those who expect it no sooner.

“Q. But may we expect it sooner?

“A. Why not?  For, although we grant, (1.)  That the generality of
believers, whom we have hitherto known, were not so sanctified till near
death; (2.)  That few of those to Whom St.  Paul wrote his Epistles were
so at that time; nor, ~(3.)  He himself at the time of writing his
former Epistles; yet all this does not prove, that we may not be so to-
day.

“Q. In what manner should we preach sanctification?

“A. Scarce at all to those who are not pressing forward: To those who
are, always by way of promise; always drawing, rather than driving.”

Our Third Conference began Tuesday, May 13, 1746.

In this we carefully read over the Minutes of the two preceding
Conferences, to observe whether anything contained therein might be
retrenched or altered on more mature consideration.  But we did not see
cause to alter in any respect what we had agreed upon before.

Our Fourth Conference began on Tuesday, June the 16th, 1747.  As
several persons were present, who did not believe the doctrine of
perfection, we agreed to examine it from the foundation.

In order to this, it was asked,

“How much is allowed by our brethren who differ from `is with regard to
entire sanctification?

“A. They grant, (1.)  That every one must be entirely sanctified in the
article of death.  (2.)  That till then a believer daily grows in grace,
comes nearer and nearer to perfection.  (3.)  That we ought to be
continually pressing after it, and to exhort all others so to do.

“Q. What do we allow them?

“A. We grant, (1.)  That many of those who have died in the faith, yea,
the greater part of those we have known, were not perfected in love till
a little before their death.  (2.)  That the term +sanctified+ is
continually applied by St.  Paul to all that were justified.  (3.)  That
by this term alone, he rarely, if ever, means `saved from all sin.’
(4.)  That, consequently, it is not proper to use it in that sense,
without adding the word +wholly, entirely,+ or the like.  (5.)  That the
inspired writers almost continually speak of or to those who were
justified, but very rarely of or to those who were wholly sanctified.
[That is, unto those alone, exclusive of others; but they speak to them,
jointly with others, almost continually.] (6.)  That, consequently, it
beloves us to speak almost continually of the state of justification;
but more rarely, [More rarely, I allow; but yet in some places very
frequently, strongly, and explicitly.] `at least in full and explicit
terms, concerning entire sanctification.’

“Q. What then is the point where we divide?

“A. It is this: Should we expect to be saved from all sin~ before the
article of death?

“Q. Is there any clear Scripture promise of this, — that God will save
us from all sin?

“A. There is: `He shall redeem Israel from all his sins.’  (Psalm
130:8.)

“This is more largely expressed in the prophecy of Ezekiel: `Then will
I sprinkle clean water upon you, and ye shall be clean; from all your
filthiness and from all your idols will I cleanse you: I will also save
you from all your uncleannesses.’  (Ezek.  36:25, 29.)  No promise can
be more clear.  And to this the Apostle plainly refers in that
exhortation: `Having these promises, let us cleanse ourselves from all
filthiness of flesh and spirit, perfecting holiness in the fear of God.’
(2 Cor.  7:1.)  Equally clear and express is that ancient promise: `The
Lord thy God will circumcise thy heart, and the heart of thy seed, to
love the Lord thy God with all thy heart and with all thy soul.’  (Deut.
30:6.)

“Q. But does any assertion answerable to this occur in the New
Testament?

“A. There does, and that laid down in the plainest terms.  So 1 John
3:8: `For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might
destroy the works of the devil;’ the works of the devil, without any
limitation or restriction; but all sin is the work of the devil.
Parallel to which is the assertion of St.  Paul: `Christ loved the
Church, and gave himself for it, that he might present it to himself a
glorious Church, not having spot or wrinkle, or any such thing, but that
it might be holy and without blemish.’  (Eph.  5:25-27.)

“And to the same effect is his assertion in the eighth of the Romans,
verses 3, 4: `God sent his Son, that the righteousness of the law might
be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh, but after the spirit.’
[Rom.  8:3, 4]

“Q. Does the New Testament afford any farther ground for expecting to
be saved from all sin?

“A. Undoubtedly it does; both in those prayers and commands, which are
equivalent to the strongest assertions.

“Q. What prayers do you mean?

“A. Prayers for entire sanctification; which, were there no such thing,
would be mere mockery of God.  Such in particular are, (1.)  `Deliver us
from evil.’  Now, when this is done, when we are delivered from all
evil, there can be no sin remaining.  (2.)  `Neither pray I for these
alone, but for them also who shall believe on me through their word;
that they all may be one; as thou, Father, art in me and I in thee, that
they also may be one in us; I in them, and thou in me, that they may be
made perfect in one.’  (John 17:20-23.)  (3.)  `I bow my knees unto the
God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, that he would grant you, that
ye, being rooted and grounded in love, may be able to comprehend, with
all saints, what is the breadth, and length, and depth, and height, and
to know the love of Christ, which passeth knowledge; that ye may be
filled with all the fulness of God.’  (Eph.  3:14, &c.)  (4.)  `The very
God of peace sanctify you wholly.  And I pray God, your whole spirit,
soul, and body, may be preserved blameless unto the coming of our Lord
Jesus Christ.’  (1 Thess.  5:23.)

“Q. What command is there to the same effect?

“A. (1.)  `Be ye perfect, as your Father who is in heaven is perfect.’
(Matt.  5:48.)  (2.)  `Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy
heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.’  (Matt.  12:37.)
But if the love of God fill all the heart, there can be no sin therein.

“Q. But how does it appear that this is to be done before the article
of death?

“A. (1.)  From the very nature of a command, which is not given to the
dead, but to the living.  Therefore, `Thou shalt love God with all thy
heart,’ cannot mean, Thou shalt do this when thou diest; but, while thou
livest.

“(2.)  From express texts of Scripture: (i.)  `The grace of God, that
bringeth salvation, hath appeared to all men; teaching us that, having
renounced ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly,
righteously, and godly in this present world; looking for the glorious
appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us, that he
might redeem us from all iniquity, and purify unto himself a peculiar
people, zealous of good works.’  (Titus 2:11-14.)~ (ii.)  `He hath
raised up an horn of salvation for us, to perform the mercy promised to
our fathers; the oath which he sware to our father Abraham, that he
would grant unto us, that we, being delivered out of the hands of our
enemies, should serve him without fear, in holiness and righteousness
before him, all the days of our life.’  (Luke 1:69, &c.)

“Q. Is there any example in Scripture of persons who had attained to
this?

“A. Yes; St.  John, and all those of whom he says, `Herein is our love
made perfect, that we may have boldness in the day of judgment; because,
as he is, so are we in this world.’  (1 John 4:17.)

“Q. Can you show one such example now?  Where is he that is thus
perfect?

“A. To some that make this inquiry one might answer, If I knew one
here, I would not tell you; for you do not inquire out of love.  You are
like Herod; you only seek the young child to slay it.

“But more directly we answer: There are many reasons why there should
be few, if any, indisputable examples.  What inconveniences would this
bring on the person himself, set as a mark for all to shoot at!  And how
unprofitable would it be to gainsayers!  `For if they hear not Moses and
the Prophets,’ Christ and his Apostles, `neither would they be persuaded
though one rose from the dead.’

“Q. Are we not apt to have a secret distaste to any who ~say they are
saved from all sin?

“A. It is very possible we may, and that upon several grounds; partly
from a concern for the good of souls, who may be hurt if these are not
what they profess; partly from a kind of implicit envy at those who
speak of higher attainments than our own; and partly from our natural
slowness and unreadiness of heart to believe the works of God.

“Q,. Why may we not continue in the joy of faith till we are perfected
in love?

“A. Why indeed?  since holy grief does not quench this joy; since even
while we are under the cross, while we deeply partake of the sufferings
of Christ, we may rejoice with joy unspeakable.”

From these extracts it undeniably appears, not only what was mine and
my brother’s judgment, but what was the judgment of all the Preachers in
connexion with us, in the years 1744, 45, 46 and 47.  Nor do I remember
that, in any one of these Conferences, we had one dissenting voice; but
whatever doubts any one had when we met, they were all removed before we
parted.

18.  In the year 1749, my brother printed two volumes of “Hymns and
Sacred Poems.”  As I did not see these before they were published, there
were some things in them which I did not approve of.  But I quite
approved of the main of the hymns on this head; a few verses of which
are subjoined : —

Come, Lord, be manifested here, And all the devil’s works destroy; Now,
without sin, in me appear, And fill with everlasting joy: Thy beatific
face display; Thy presence is the perfect day.  (Vol.  I., p.  203.)

Swift to my rescue come, Thy own this moment seize; Gather my wand’ring
spirit home, And keep in perfect peace.

Suffer’d no more to rove O’er all the earth abroad, Arrest the pris’ner
of thy love, And shut me up in God!  (Page 247.)

Thy pris’ners release, Vouchsafe us thy peace; And our sorrows and sins
in a moment shall cease.  That moment be now!  Our petition allow, Our
present Redeemer and Comforter thou!  (Vol.  II., p.  124.)

From this inbred sin deliver; Let the yoke Now be broke; Make me thine
for ever.

Partner of thy perfect nature, Let me be Now in thee A new, sinless
creature.  (Page 156.)

Turn me, Lord, and turn me now, To thy yoke my spirit bow; Grant me now
the pearl to find Of a meek and quiet mind.

Calm, O calm my troubled breast; Let me gain that second rest: From my
works for ever cease, Perfected in holiness.  (Page 162.)

Come in this accepted hour, Bring thy heavenly kingdom in!  Fill us
with the glorious power; Rooting out the seeds of sin.  (Page 168.)

Come, thou dear Lamb, for sinners slain, Bring in the cleansing flood;
Apply, to wash out every stain, Thine efficacious blood.

O let~ it sink into our soul Deep as the inbred sin: Make every wounded
spirit whole, And every leper clean!  (Page 171.)

Pris’ners of hope arise, And see your Lord appear: Lo!  on the wings of
love he flies, And brings redemption near.

Redemption in his blood He calls you to receive: “Come unto me, the
pard’ning God: Believe,” he cries, “believe!”

Jesus, to thee we look, Till saved from sin’s remains, Reject the
inbred tyrant’s yoke, And cast away his chains.

Our nature shall no more O’er us dominion have: By faith we apprehend
the power, Which shall for ever save.  (Page 188.)

Jesu, our life, in us appear, Who daily die thy death: Reveal thyself
the finisher; Thy quick’ning Spirit breathe!~

Unfold the hidden mystery, The second gift impart; Reveal thy glorious
self in me, In every waiting heart.  (Page 195.)

In Him we have peace, In Him we have power!  Preserved by his grace
Throughout the dark hour, In all our temptation He keeps us, to prove
His utmost salvation, His fulness of love.

Pronounce the glad word, And bid us be free!  Ah, hast thou not, Lord,
A blessing for me?  The peace thou hast given, This moment impart, And
open thy heaven, O Love, in my heart!  (Page 324.)

A second edition of these hymns Was published in the year 1752; and
that without any other alteration, than that of a few literal mistakes.

I have been the more large in these extracts, because hence it appears,
beyond all possibility of exception, that to this day both my brother
and I maintained, (1.)  That Christian perfection is that love of God
and our neighbour, which implies deliverance from all sin.  (2.)  That
this is received merely by faith.  (3.)  That it is given
instantaneously, in one moment.  (4.)  That we are to expect it, not at
death, but every moment; that now is the accepted time, now is the day
of this salvation.

19.  At the Conference in the year 1759, perceiving som~e danger that a
diversity of sentiments should insensibly steal in among us, we again
largely considered this doctrine; and soon after I published “Thoughts
on Christian Perfection,” prefaced with the following advertisement: —

“The following tract is by no means designed to gratify the curiosity
of any man.  It is not intended to prove the doctrine at large, in
opposition to those who explode and ridicule it; no, nor to answer the
numerous objections against it, which may be raised even by serious men.
All I intend here is, simply to declare what are my sentiments on this
head; what Christian perfection does, according to my apprehension,
include, and what it does not; and to add a few practical observations
and directions relative to the subject.

“As these thoughts were at first thrown together by way of question and
answer, I let them continue in the same form.  They are just the same
that I have entertained for above twenty years.

“QUESTION. What is Christian perfection?

“ANSWER. The loving God with all our heart, mind, soul, and strength.
This implies, that no wrong temper, none contrary to love, remains in
the soul; and that all the thoughts, words, and actions, are governed by
pure love.

“Q. Do you affirm, that this perfection excludes all infirmities,
ignorance, and mistake?

“A. I continually affirm quite the contrary, and always have done so.

“Q. But how can every thought, word, and work, be governed by pure
love, and the man be subject at the same time to ignorance and mistake?

“A. I see no contradiction here: `A man may be filled with pure love,
and still be liable to mistake.’  Indeed I do not expect to be freed
from actual mistakes, till this mortal puts on immortality.  I believe
this to be a natural consequence of the soul’s dwelling in flesh and
blood.  For we cannot now think at all, but by the mediation of those
bodily organs which have suffered equally with the rest of our frame.
And hence we cannot avoid sometimes thinking wrong, till this
corruptible shall have put on incorruption.

“But we may carry this thought farther yet.  A mistake in judgment may
possibly occasion a mistake in practice.  For instance: Mr.  De Renty’s
mistake touching the nature of mortification, arising from prejudice of
education, occasioned that practical mistake, his wearing an iron
girdle.  And a thousand such instances there may be, even in those who
are in the highest state of grace.  Yet, Where every word and action
springs from love, such a mistake is not properly a sin.  However, it
cannot bear the rigour of God’s justice,~ but needs the atoning blood.

“Q. What was the judgment of all our brethren who met~ at Bristol in
August, 1758, on this head?

“A. It was expressed in these words: (1.)  Every one may mistake as
long as he lives.  (2.)  A mistake in opinion may occasion a mistake in
practice.  (3.)  Every such mistake is a transgression of the perfect
law.  Therefore, (4.)  Every such mistake, were it not for the blood of
atonement, would expose to eternal damnation.  (5.)  It follows, that
the most~ perfect have continual need of the merits of Christ, even for
their actual transgressions, and may say for themselves, as well as for
their brethren, `Forgive us our trespasses.’

“This easily accounts for what might otherwise seem to be utterly
unaccountable; namely, that those who are not offended when We speak of
the highest degree of love, yet will not hear of living without sin.
The reason is, they know all men are liable to mistake, and that in
practice as well as in judgment.  But they do not know, or do not
observe, that this is not sin, if love is the sole principle of action.

“Q. But still, if they live without sin, does not this exclude the
necessity of a Mediator?  At least, is it not plain that they stand no
longer in need of Christ in his priestly office ?~

“A. Far from it.  None feel their need of Christ like these; none so
entirely depend upon him.  For Christ does not give life to the soul
separate from, but in and with, himself.  Hence his words are equally
true of all men, in whatsoever state of grace they are: `As the branch
cannot bear fruit of itself, except it abide in the vine; no more can
ye, except ye abide in me: Without’ (or separate from) `me ye can do
nothing.’

“In every state we need Christ in the following respects (1.)  Whatever
grace we receive, it is a free gift from him.  (2.)  We receive it as
his purchase, merely in consideration of the price he paid.  (3.)  We
have this grace, not only from Christ, but in him.  For our perfection
is not like that of a tree, which flourishes by the sap derived from its
own root, but, as was said before, like that of a branch which, united
to the vine, bears fruit; but, severed from it, is dried up and
withered.  (4.)  All our blessings, temporal, spiritual, and eternal,
depend on his intercession for us, which is one branch of his priestly
office, whereof therefore we have always equal ~need.  (5.)  The best of
men still need Christ in his priestly office, to atone for their
omissions, their short-comings, (as some not improperly speak,) their
mistakes in judgment and practice, and their defects of various kinds.
For these are all deviations from the perfect law, and consequently need
an atonement.  Yet that they are not properly sins, we apprehend may
appear from the words of St.  Paul, `He that loveth, hath fulfilled the
law; for love is the fulfilling of the law.’  (Rom.  13:10.)  Now,
mistakes, and whatever infirmities necessarily flow from the corruptible
state of the body, are noway contrary to love; nor therefore, in the
Scripture sense, sin.

“To explain myself a little farther on this head: (1.)  Not only sin,
properly so called, (that is, a voluntary transgression of a known law,)
but sin, improperly so called, (that is, an involuntary transgression of
a divine law, known or unknown,) needs the atoning blood.  (2.)  I
believe there is no such perfection in this life as excludes these
involuntary transgressions which I apprehend to be naturally consequent
on the ignorance and mistakes inseparable from mortality.  (3.)
Therefore sinless perfection is a phrase I never use, lest I should seem
to contradict myself.  (4.)  I believe, a person filled with the love of
God is still liable to these involuntary transgressions.  (5.)  Such
transgressions you may call sins, if you please: I do not, for the
reasons above-mentioned.

“Q. What advice would you give to those that do, and those that do not,
call them so?

“A. Let those that do not call them sins, never think that themselves
or any other persons are in such a state as that they can stand before
infinite justice without a Mediator.  This must argue either the deepest
ignorance, or the highest arrogance and presumption.

“Let those who do call them so, be~ware how they confound these defects
with sins, properly so called.

“But how will they avoid it?  How will these be distinguished from
those, if they are all promiscuously called sins?  I am much afraid, if
we should allow any sins to be consistent with perfection, few would
confine the idea to those defects concerning which only the assertion
could be true.

“Q. But how can a liableness to mistake consist with perfect love?  Is
not a person who is perfected in love every moment under its influence?
And can any mistake flow from pure love?

“A. I answer, (1.)  Many mistakes may consist with pure love; (2.)
Some may accidentally flow from it: I mean, love itself may incline us
to mistake.  The pure love of our neighbour, springing from the love of
God, thinketh no evil, believeth and hopeth all things.  Now, this very
temper, unsuspicious, ready to believe and hope the best of all men, may
occasion our thinking some men better than they really are.  Here then
is a manifest mistake, accidentally flowing from pure love.

“Q. How shall we avoid setting perfection too high or too low?

“A. By keeping to the Bible, and setting it just as high as the
Scripture does.  It is nothing higher and nothing lower than this,–the
pure love of God and man; the loving God with all our heart and soul,
and our neighbour as ourselves.  It is love governing the heart and
life, running through all our tempers, words, and actions.

“Q. Suppose one had attained to this, would you advise him to speak of
it?

“A. At first perhaps he would scarce be able to refrain, the fire would
be so hot within him; his desire to declare the loving-kindness of the
Lord carrying him away like a torrent.  But afterwards he might; and
then it would be advisable, not to speak of it to them that know not
God; (it is most likely, it would only provoke them to contradict and
blaspheme;) nor to others, without some particular reason, without some
good in view.  And then he should have especial care to avoid all
appearance of boasting; to speak with the deepest humility and
reverence, giving all the glory to God.

“Q. But would it not be better to be entirely silent, not to speak of
it at all?

“A. By silence, he might avoid many crosses, which will naturally and
necessarily ensue, if he simply declare, even among believers, what God
has wrought in his soul.  If, there- fore, such a one were to confer
with flesh and blood he would be entirely silent.  But this could not be
done with a clear conscience; for undoubtedly he ought to speak.  Men do
not light a candle to put it under a bushel; much less does the all-wise
God.  He does not raise such a monument of his power and love, to hide
it from all mankind.  Rather, he intends it as a general blessing to
those who are simple of heart.  He designs thereby, not barely the
happiness of that individual person, but the animating and encouraging
others to follow after the same blessing.  His will is, `that many shall
see it’ and rejoice, `and put their trust in the Lord.’  Nor does
anything under heaven more quicken the desires of those Who are
justified, than to converse with those whom they believe to have
experienced a still higher salvation.  This places that salvation full
in their view, and increases their hunger and thirst after it; an
advantage which must have been entirely lost, had the person so saved
buried himself in silence.

“Q. But is there no way to prevent these crosses which usually fall on
those who speak of being thus saved?

“A. It seems they cannot be prevented altogether, while so much of
nature remains even in believers.  But something might be done, if the
Preacher in every place would, (1.)  Talk freely with all who speak
thus; and, (2.)  Labour to prevent the unjust or unkind treatment of
those in favour of whom there is reasonable proof.

“Q. What is reasonable proof?  How may we certainly know one that is
saved from all sin?

“A. We cannot infallibly know one that is thus saved, (no, nor even one
that is justified,) unless it should please ~God to endow us with the
miraculous discernment of spirits.  But we apprehend those would be
sufficient proofs to any reasonable man, and such as would leave little
room to doubt either the truth or depth of the work: (1.)  If we had
clear evidence of his exemplary behaviour for some time before this
supposed change.  This would give us reason to believe, ~he would not
`lie for God,’ but speak neither more nor less than he felt; (2.)  If he
gave a distinct account of the time and manner wherein the change was
wrought, with sound speech which could not be reproved; and, (3.)  If it
appeared that all his subsequent words and actions were holy and
unblamable.

“The short of the matter is this: (1.)  I have abundant reason to
believe, this person will not lie; (2.)  He testifies before God, `I
feel no sin, but all love; I pray, rejoice, and give thanks without
ceasing; and I have as clear an inward witness, that I am fully renewed,
as that I am justified.’  Now, if I have nothing to oppose to this plain
testimony, I ought in reason to believe it.

“It avails nothing to object, `But I know several things wherein he is
quite mistaken.’  For it has been allowed, that all who are in the body
are liable to mistake; and that a mistake in judgment may sometimes
occasion a mistake in practice; though great care is to be taken that no
ill use be made of this concession.  For instance: Even one that is
perfected in love may mistake with regard to another person, and may
think him, in a particular case, to be more or less faulty than he
really is.  And hence he may speak to him with more or less severity
than the truth requires.  And in this sense, (though that be not the
primary meaning of St.  James,) `in many things we offend all.’  This
therefore is no proof at all, that the person so speaking is not
perfect.

“Q. But is it not a proof, if he is surprised or fluttered by a noise,
a fall, or some sudden danger?

“A. It is not; for one may start, tremble, change colour, or be
otherwise disordered in body, while the soul is calmly stayed on God,
and remains in perfect peace.  Nay, the mind itself may be deeply
distressed, may be exceeding sorrowful, may be perplexed and pressed
down by heaviness and anguish, even to agony, while the heart cleaves to
God by perfect love, and the will is wholly resigned to him.  Was it not
so with the Son of God himself?  Does any child of man endure the
distress, the anguish, the agony, which he sustained?  And yet he knew
no sin.

“Q. But can any one who has a pure heart prefer pleasing to unpleasing
food; or use any pleasure of sense which is not strictly necessary?  If
so, how do they differ from others?

“A. The difference between these and others in taking pleasant food is,
(1.)  They need none of these things to make them happy; for they have a
spring of happiness within.  They see and love God.  Hence they rejoice
evermore, and in everything give thanks.  (2.)  They may use them, but
they do not seek them.  (3.)  They use them sparingly, and not for the
sake of the thing itself.  This being premised, we answer directly, —
Such a one may use pleasing food, without the danger which attends those
who are not saved from sin.  He may prefer it to unpleasing, though
equally wholesome, food, as a means of increasing thankfulness, with a
single eye to God, who giveth US all things richly to enjoy: On the same
principle, he may smell to a flower, or eat a bunch of grapes, or take
any other pleasure which does not lessen but increase his delight in
God.  Therefore, neither can we say that one perfected in love would be
incapable of marriage, and of worldly business: If he were called
thereto, he would be more capable than ever; as being able to do all
things without hurry or carefulness, without any distraction of spirit.

“Q. But if two perfect Christians had chil~dren, how could they be born
in sin, since there was none in the parents?

“A. It is a possible, but not a probable, case; I doubt whether it ever
was or ever will be.  But waving this, I answer, Sin is entailed upon
me, not by immediate generation, but by my first parent.  `In Adam all
died; by the disobedience of one, all men were made sinners;’ all men,
without exception, who were in his loins when he ate the forbidden
fruit.

“We have a remarkable illustration of this in gardening: Grafts on a
crab-stock bear excellent fruit; but sow the kernels of this fruit, and
what will be the event?  They produce as mere crabs as ever were eaten.

“Q. But what does the perfect one do more than others?  more than the
common believers?

“A. Perhaps nothing; so may the providence of God have hedged him in by
outward circumstances.  Perhaps not so much; though he desires and longs
to spend and be spent for God; at least, not externally: He neither
speaks so many words, nor does so many works.  As neither did our Lord
himself speak so many words, or do so many, no, nor so great works, as
some of his Apostles.  (John 14:12.)  But what then?  This is no proof
that he has not more grace; and by this God measures the outward work.
Hear ye Him: `Verily, I say unto you, this poor widow has cast in more
than them all.’  Verily, this poor man, with his few broken words, hath
spoken more than them all.  Verily, this poor woman, that hath given a
c~up of cold water, hath done more than them all.  O cease to `judge
according to appearance,’ and learn to `judge righteous judgment!’

“Q. But is not this a proof against him, — I feel no power either in
his words or prayer?

“A. It is not; for perhaps that is your own fault.  You are not likely
to feel any power therein, if any of these hinderances lie in the way:
(1.)  Your own deadness of soul.  The dead Pharisees felt no power even
in His words who `spake as never man spake.’  (2.)  The guilt of some
unrepented sin lying upon the conscience.  (3.)  Prejudice toward him of
any kind.  (4.)  Your not believing that state to be attainable wherein
he professes to be.  (5.)  Unreadiness to think or own he has attained
it.  (6.)  Overvaluing or idolizing him.  (7.)  Overvaluing yourself and
your own judgment.  If any of these is the case, what wonder is it that
you feel no power in anything he says?  But do not others feel it?  If
they do, your argument falls to the ground.  And if they do not, do none
of these hinderances lie in their way too?  You must be certain of this
before you can build any argument thereon; and even then your argument
will prove no more than that grace and gifts do not always go together.

“`But he does not come up to my idea of a perfect Christian.’  And
perhaps no one ever did, or ever will.  For your idea may go beyond, or
at least beside, the scriptural account.  It may include more than the
Bible includes therein, or, however, something which that does not
include.  Scripture perfection is, pure love filling the heart, and
governing all the words and actions.  If your idea includes anything
more or anything else, it is not scriptural; and then no wonder, that a
scripturally perfect Christian does not come up to it.

“I fear many stumble on this stumbling-block.  They include as many
ingredients as they please, not according to Scripture, but their own
imagination, in their idea of one that is perfect; and then readily deny
any one to be such, who does not answer that imaginary idea.

“The more care should we take to keep the simple, scriptural account
continually in our eye.  Pure love reigning alone in the heart and life,
— this is the whole of scriptural perfection.

“Q. When may a person judge himself to have attained this?

“A. When, after having been fully convinced of inbred sin, by a far
deeper and clearer conviction than that he experienced before
justification, and after having experienced a gradual mortification of
it, he experiences a total death to sin, and an entire renewal in the
love and image of God, so as to rejoice evermore, to pray without
ceasing, and in everything to give thanks.  Not that `to feel all love
and no sin’ is a sufficient proof.  Several have experienced this for a
time, before their souls were fully renewed.  None therefore ought to
believe that the work is done, till there is added the testimony of the
Spirit, witnessing his entire sanctification, as clearly as his
justification.

“Q. But whence is it, that some imagine they are thus sanctified, when
in reality they are not?

“A. It is hence; they do not judge by all the preceding marks, but
either by part of them, or by others that are ambiguous.  But I know no
instance of a person attending to them all, and yet deceived in this
matter.  I believe, there can be none in the world.  If a man be deeply
and fully convinced, after justification, of inbred sin; if he then
experience a gradual mortification of sin, and afterwards an entire
renewal in the image of God; if to this change, immensely greater than
that wrought when he was justified, be added a clear, direct witness of
the renewal; I judge it as impossible this man should be deceived
herein, as that God should lie.  And if one whom I know to be a man of
veracity testify these things to me, I ought not, without some
sufficient reason, to reject his testimony.

“Q. Is this death to sin, and renewal in love, gradual or
instantaneous?

“A. A man may he dying for some time; yet he does not, properly
speaking, die, till the instant the soul is separated from the body; and
in that instant he lives the life of eternity.  In like manner, he may
be dying to sin for some time; yet he is not dead to sin, till sin is
separated from his soul; and in that instant he lives the full life of
love.  And as the change undergone, when the body dies, is of a
different kind, and infinitely greater than any we had known before,
yea, such as till then it is impossible to conceive; so the change
wrought, when the soul dies to sin, is of a different kind, and
infinitely greater than any before, and than any can conceive till he
experiences it.  Yet he stills grows iii grace, in the knowledge of
Christ, in the love and image of God; and will do so, not only till
death, but to all eternity.

“Q. How are we to wait for this change?

“A. Not in careless indifference, or indolent inactivity; but in
vigorous, universal obedience, in a zealous keeping of all the
commandments, in watchfulness and painfulness, in denying ourselves, and
taking up our cross daily; as well as in earnest prayer and fasting and
a close attendance on all the ordinances of God.  And if any man dream
of attaining it any other way, (yea, or of keeping it when it is
attained, when he has received it even in the largest measure,) he
deceive his own soul.  It is true, we receive it by simple faith: But
God does not, will not, give that faith, unless we seek it with all
diligence, in the way which he hath ordained.

“This consideration may satisfy those who inquire, why so few have
received the blessing.  Inquire, how many are seeking it in this way;
and you have a sufficient answer.

“Prayer especially is wanting.  Who continues instant therein?  Who
wrestles with God for this very thing?  So,`ye have not, because ye ask
not; or because ye ask amiss,’ namely, that you may be renewed before
you die.  +Before you die!+ Will that content you?  Nay, but ask that it
may be done now; to-day, while it is called to-day.  Do not call this
`setting God a time.’  Certainly, to-day is his time as well as to-
morrow.  Make haste, man, make haste!  Let

Thy soul break out in strong desire The perfect bliss to prove; Thy
longing heart be all on fire To be dissolved in love!

“Q. But may we not continue in peace and joy till we are perfected in
love?

“A. Certainly we may; for the kingdom of God is not divided against
itself; therefore, let not believers be discouraged from `rejoicing in
the Lord always.’  And yet we may be sensibly pained at the sinful
nature that still remains in us.  It is good for us to have a piercing
sense of this, and a vehement desire to he delivered from it.  But this
should only incite us the more zealously to fly every moment to our
strong Helper, the more earnestly to `press forward to the mark, the
prize of our high calling in Christ Jesus.’  And when the sense of our
sin most abounds, the sense of his love should much more abound.

“Q. How should we treat those who think they have attained?

“A. Examine them candidly, and exhort them to pray fervently, that God
would show them all that is in their hearts.  The most earnest
exhortations to abound in every grace, and the strongest cautions to
avoid all evil, are given throughout the New Testament, to those who are
in the highest state of grace.  But this should be done with the utmost
tenderness; and without any harshness, sternness or sourness.  We should
carefully avoid the very appearance of anger, unkindness, or contempt.
Leave it to Satan thus to tempt, and to his children to cry out, `Let us
examine him with despitefulness and torture, that we may know his
meekness and prove his patience.’  If they are faithful to the grace
given, they are in no danger of perishing thereby; no, not if they
remain in that mistake till their spirit is returning to God.

“Q. But what hurt can it do to deal harshly with them?

“A. Either they are mistaken, or they are not.  If they are, it may
destroy their souls.  This is nothing impossible, no, nor improbable.
It may so enrage or so discourage them, that they will sink and rise no
more.  If they are not mistaken, it may grieve those whom God has not
grieved, and do much hurt unto our own souls.  For undoubtedly he that
toucheth them, toucheth, as it were, the apple of God’s eye.  If they
are indeed full of his Spirit, to behave unkindly or contemptuously to
them is doing no little despite to the Spirit of grace.  Hereby,
likewise, we feed and increase in ourselves evil surmising, and many
wrong tempers.  To instance only in one: What self-sufficiency is this,
to set ourselves up for inquisitors-general, for peremptory judges in
these deep things of God!  Are we qualified for the office?  Can we
pronounce, in all cases, how far infirmity reaches?  what may, and what
may not, be resolved into it?  what may in all circumstances, and what
may not, consist with perfect love?  Can we precisely determine, how it
will influence the look, the gesture, the tone of voice?  If we can,
doubtless we are `the men, and wisdom shall die with us.’

“Q. But if they are displeased at our not believing them, is not this a
full proof against them?

“A. According as that displeasure is: If they are angry, it is a proof
against them; if they are grieved, it is not.  They ought to be grieved,
if we disbelieve a real work of God, and thereby deprive ourselves of
the advantage we might have received from it.  And we may easily mistake
this grief for anger, as the outward expressions of both are much alike.

“Q. But is it not well to find out those who fancy they have attained
when they have not?

“A. It is well to do it by mild, loving examination.  But it is not
well to triumph even over these.  It is extremely wrong, if we find such
an instance, to rejoice as if we had found great spoils.  Ought we not
rather to grieve, to be deeply concerned, to let our eyes run down with
tears?  Here is one who seemed to be a living proof of God’s power to
save to the uttermost; but, alas, it is not as we hoped.  He is weighed
ill the balance, and found wanting!  And is this matter of joy?  Ought
we not to rejoice a thousand times more, if we can find nothing but pure
love?

“`But he is deceived.’  What then?  It is a harmless mistake, while he
feels nothing but love in his heart.  It is a mistake which generally
argues great grace, an high degree both of holiness and happiness.  This
should be a matter of real joy to all that are simple of heart; not the
mistake itself, but the height of grace which for a time occasions it.
I rejoice that this soul is always happy in Christ, always full of
prayer and thanksgiving.  I rejoice that he feels no unholy temper, but
the pure love of God continually.  And I will rejoice, if sin is
suspended till it is totally destroyed.

“Q. Is there no danger then in a man’s being thus deceived?

“A. Not at the time that he feels no sin.  There was danger before, and
there will be again when he comes into fresh trials.  But so long as he
feels nothing but love animating all his thoughts, and words, and
actions, he is in no danger; he is not only happy, but safe, `under the
shadow of the Almighty;’ and, for God’s sake, let him continue in that
love as long as he can.  Meantime, you may do well to warn him of the
danger that will be, if his love grow cold and sin revive; even the
danger of casting away hope, and supposing, that, because he hath not
attained yet, therefore he never shall.

“Q. But what, if none have attained it yet?  What, if all who think so
are deceived?

“A. Convince me of this, and I will preach it no more.  But understand
me right: I do not build any doctrine on this or that person.  This or
any other man may be deceived, and I am not moved.  But, if there are
none made perfect yet, God has not sent me to preach perfection.

“Put a parallel case: For many years I have preached, `There is a peace
of God which passeth all understanding?  Convince me that this word has
fallen to the ground; that in all these years none have attained this
peace; that there is no living witness of it at this day; and I will
preach it no more.

“`O, but several persons have died in that peace.’  Perhaps so; but I
want living witnesses.  I cannot indeed be infallibly certain that this
or that person is a witness; but if I were certain there are none such,
I must have done with this doctrine.

“`You misunderstand me.  I believe some who died in this love, enjoyed
it long before their death.  But I was not certain that their former
testimony was true till some hours before they died.’

“You had not an infallible certainty then: And a reasonable certainty
you might have had before; such a certainty as might have quickened and
comforted your own soul, and answered all other Christian purposes.
Such a certainty as this, any candid person may have, suppose there be
any living witness, by talking one hour with that person in the love and
fear of God.

“Q. But what does it signify, whether any have attained it or no,
seeing so many scriptures witness for it?

“A. If I were convinced that none in England had attained what has been
so clearly and strongly preached by such a number of Preachers, in so
many places, and for so long a time, I should be clearly convinced that
we had all mistaken the meaning of those scriptures; and therefore, for
the time to come, I too must teach that `sin will remain till death.'”

 20.  In the year 1762, there was a great increase of the work of God
in London.  Many, who had hitherto cared for none of these things, were
deeply convinced of their lost estate; many found redemption in the
blood of Christ; not a few backsliders were healed; and a considerable
number of persons believed that God had saved them from all sin.  Easily
foreseeing that Satan would be endeavouring to sow tares among the
wheat, I took much pains to apprize them of the danger, particularly
with regard to pride and enthusiasm.  And while I stayed in town, I had
reason to hope they continued both humble and sober-minded.  But almost
as soon as I was gone enthusiasm broke in.  Two or three began to take
their own imaginations for impressions from God, and thence to suppose
that they should never die; and these, labouring to bring others into
the same opinion, occasioned much noise and confusion.  Soon after, the
same persons, with a few more, ran into other extravagances; fancying
they could not be tempted; that they should feel no more pain; and that
they had the gift of prophecy, and of discerning of spirits.  At my
return to London, in autumn, some of them stood reproved; but others
were got above instruction.  Meantime, a flood of reproach came upon me
almost from every quarter; from themselves, because I was checking them
on all occasions; and from others, because, they said, I did not check
them.  However, the hand of the Lord was not stayed, but more and more
sinners were convinced; while some were almost daily converted to God,
and others enabled to love him with all their heart.

21.  About this time, a friend at some distance from London wrote to me
as follows: —

“Be not over alarmed that Satan sows tares among the wheat of Christ.
It ever has been so, especially on any remarkable outpouring of his
Spirit; and ever will be so, till he is chained up for a thousand years.
Till then he will always ape, and endeavour to counteract, the work of
the Spirit of Christ.

“One melancholy effect of this has been, that a world, who is always
asleep in the arms of the evil one, has ridiculed every work of the Holy
Spirit.

“But what can real Christians do?  Why, if they would act worthy of
themselves, they should, (1.)  Pray that every deluded soul may be
delivered; (2.)  Endeavour to reclaim them in the spirit of meekness;
and, Lastly, take the utmost care, both by prayer and watchfulness, that
the delusion of others may not lessen their zeal in seeking after that
universal holiness of soul, body, and spirit, `without which no man
shall see the Lord.’

“Indeed this complete new creature is mere madness to a mad world.  But
it is, notwithstanding, the will and wisdom of God.  May we all seek
after it!

“But some who maintain this doctrine in its full extent are too often
guilty of limiting the Almighty.  He dispenses his gifts just as he
pleases; therefore, it is neither wise nor modest to affirm that a
person must be a believer for any length of time before he is capable of
receiving a high degree of the Spirit of holiness.

“God’s usual method is one thing, but his sovereign pleasure is
another.  He has wise reasons both for hastening and retarding his work.
Sometimes he comes suddenly and unexpected; sometimes, not till we have
long looked for him.

“Indeed it has been my opinion for many years, that one great cause why
men make so little improvement in the divine life is their own coldness,
negligence, and unbelief.  And yet I here speak of believers.

“May the Spirit of Christ give us a right judgment in all things, and
`fill us with all the fulness of God;’ that so we may be `perfect and
entire, wanting nothing.'”

22.  About the same time, five or six honest enthusiasts foretold the
world was to end on the 28th of February.  I immediately withstood them,
by every possible means, both in public and private.  I preached
expressly upon the subject, both at West-Street and Spitalfields.  I
warned the society, again and again, and spoke severally to as many as I
could; and I saw the fruit of my labour.  They made exceeding few
converts: I believe scarce thirty in our whole society.  Nevertheless,
they made abundance of noise, gave huge occasion of offence to those who
took care to improve to the uttermost every occasion against me, and
greatly increased both the number and courage of those who opposed
Christian perfection.

23.  Some questions, now published by one of these, induced a plain man
to write the following —

“QUERIES, humbly proposed to those who deny perfection to be attainable
in this life.

“(1.)  Has there not been a larger measure of the Holy Spirit given
under the Gospel, than under the Jewish dispensation?  If not, in what
sense was the Spirit not given before Christ was glorified?  (John
7:39.)

“(2.)  Was that `glory which followed the sufferings of Christ,’ (1
Peter 1:11,) an external glory, or an internal, viz., the glory of
holiness?

“(3.)  Has God anywhere in Scripture commanded us more than he has
promised to us?

“(4.)  Are the promises of God respecting holiness to be fulfilled in
this life, or only in the next?

“(5.)  Is a Christian under any other laws than those which God
promises to `write in our hearts?’  (Jer.  31:31, &c.; Heb.  8:10.)

“(6.)  In what sense is `the righteousness of the law fulfilled in
those who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit?’  (Rom.  8:4.)

“(7.)  Is it impossible for any one in this life to `love God with all
his heart, and mind, and soul, and strength?’  And is the Christian
under any law which is not fulfilled in this love?

“(8.)  Does the soul’s going out of the body effect its purification
from indwelling sin?

“(9.)  If so, is it not something else, not `the blood of Christ which
cleanseth’ it `from all sin?’

“(10.)  If his blood cleanseth us from all sin, while the soul and body
are united, is it not in this life?

“(11.)  If when that union ceases, is it not in the next?  And is not
this too late?

“(12.)  If in the article of death; what situation is the soul in, when
it is neither in the body nor out of it?

“(13.)  Has Christ anywhere taught us to pray for what he never designs
to give?

“(14.)  Has he not taught us to pray, ‘Thy will be done on earth, as it
is done in heaven?’  And is it not done perfectly in heaven?

“(15.)  If so, has he not taught us to pray for perfection on earth?
Does he not then design to give it?

“(16.)  Did not St.  Paul pray according to the will of God, when he
prayed that the Thessalonians might be `sanctified wholly, and
preserved’ (in this world, not the next, unless he was praying for the
dead) `blameless in body, soul, and spirit, unto the coming of Jesus
Christ?’

“(17.)  Do you sincerely desire to be freed from indwelling sin in this
life?

“(18.)  If you do, did not God give you that desire?

“(19.)  If so, did he not give it you to mock you, since it is
impossible it should ever be fulfilled?

“(20.)  If you have not sincerity enough even to desire it, are you not
disputing about matters too high for you?

“(21.)  Do you ever pray God to `cleanse the thoughts of your heart,
that’ you `may perfectly love him?’

“(22.)  If you neither desire what you ask, nor believe it attainable,
pray you not as a fool prayeth?

“God help thee to consider these questions calmly and impartially!”

24.  In the latter end of this year, God called to himself that burning
and shining light, Jane Cooper.  As she was both a living and a dying
witness of Christian perfection, it will not be at all foreign to the
subject to add a short account of her death; with one of her own
letters, containing a plain and artless relation of the manner wherein
it pleased God to work that great change in her soul: —

“May 2, 1761.

“I believe while memory remains in me, gratitude will continue.  From
the time you preached on Gal.  5:5, I saw clearly the true state of my
soul.  That sermon described my heart, and what it wanted to be; namely,
truly happy.  You read Mr.  M—‘s letter, and it described the religion
which I desired.  From that time the prize appeared in view, and I was
enabled to follow hard after it.  I was kept watching unto prayer,
sometimes in much distress, at other times in patient expectation of the
blessing.  For some days before you left London, my soul was stayed on a
promise I had applied to me in prayer: `The Lord whom ye seek shall
suddenly come to his temple.’  I believed he would, and that he would
sit there as a refiner’s fire.  The Tuesday after you went, I thought I
could not sleep, unless he fulfilled his word that night.  I never knew
as I did then the force of these words: `Be still, and know that I am
God.’  I became nothing before Him, and enjoyed perfect calmness in my
soul.  I knew not whether he had destroyed my sin; but I desired to
know, that I might praise Him.  Yet I soon found the return of unbelief,
and groaned, being burdened.  On Wednesday I went to London, and sought
the Lord without ceasing.  I promised, if he would save me from sin, I
would praise him.  I could part with all things, so I might win Christ.
But I found all these pleas to be nothing worth; and that if He saved
me, it must be freely, for his own name’s sake.  On Thursday I was so
much tempted, that I thought of destroying myself, or never conversing
more with the people of God: And yet I had no doubt of his pardoning
love; but, —

‘Twas worse than death my God to love, And not my God alone.

On Friday my distress was deepened.  I endeavoured to pray, and could
not.  I went to Mrs.  D., who prayed for me, and told me it was the
death of nature.  I opened the Bible, on, `The fearful and unbelieving
shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and
brimstone.’  I could not bear it.  I opened again, on Mark 16:6, 7: `Be
not affrighted; ye seek Jesus of Nazareth.  Go your way; tell his
disciples he goeth before you into Galilee; there ye shall see him.’  I
was encouraged, and enabled to pray, believing I should see Jesus at
home.  I returned that night, and found Mrs.  G. She prayed for me; and
the Predestinarian had no plea, but, `Lord, thou art no respecter of
persons.’  He proved he was not, by blessing me.  I was in a moment
enabled to lay hold on Jesus Christ, and found salvation by simple
faith.  He assured me, the Lord, the King, was in the midst of me, and
that I should see evil no more.  I now blessed Him who had visited and
redeemed me, and was become my `wisdom, righteousness, sanctification,
and redemption.’  I saw Jesus altogether lovely; and knew he was mine in
all his offices.  And, glory be to Him, He now reigns in my heart
without a rival.  I find no will but his.  I feel no pride; nor any
affection but what is placed on Him.  I know it is by faith I stand; and
that watching unto prayer must be the guard of faith.  I am happy in God
this moment, and I believe for the next.  I have often read the chapter
you mention, (1 Cor.  13.,) and compared my heart and life with it.  In
so doing, I feel my shortcomings, and the need I have of the atoning
blood.  Yet I dare not say, I do not feel a measure of the love there
described, though I am not all I shall be.  I desire to be lost in that
`love which passeth knowledge.’  I see ‘the just shall live by faith;’
and unto me, who am less than the least of all saints, is this grace
given.  If I were an archangel, I should veil my face before him, and
let silence speak his praise!”

The following account is given by one who was an eye and ear witness of
what she relates: —

“(1.)  In the beginning of November, she seemed to have a foresight of
what was coming upon her, and used frequently to sing these words: —

`When pain o’er this weak flesh prevails, With lamb-like patience arm
my breast.’

And when she sent to me, to let me know she was ill, she wrote in her
note, `I suffer the will of Jesus.  All he sends is sweetened by His
love.  I am as happy as if I heard a voice say, —

`For me my elder brethren stay, And angels beckon me away, And Jesus
bids me come!’

“(2.)  Upon my telling her, ‘I cannot choose life or death for you,’
she said, `I asked the Lord, that, if it was His will I might die first.
And he told me, you should survive me, and that you should close my
eyes.’  When we perceived it was the small-pox, I said to her, `My dear,
you will not be frighted if we tell you what is your distemper.’  She
said, `I cannot be frighted at His will.’

“(3.)  The distemper was so very heavy upon her; but so much the more
was her faith strengthened.  Tuesday, November 16, she said to me, `I
have been worshipping before the throne in a glorious manner; my soul
was so let into God!’  I said, `Did the Lord give you any particular
promise?’  `No,’ replied she; `it was all

That sacred awe that dares not move, And all the silent heaven of
love.’

“(4.)  On Thursday, upon my asking, `What have you to say to me?’  she
said, `Nay, nothing but what you know already: God is love.’  I asked,
`Have you any particular promise?’  She replied, `I do not seem to want
any; I can live without.  I shall die a lump of deformity, but shall
meet you all-glorious: And, meantime, I shall still have fellowship with
your spirit.’

“(5.)  Mr.  M. asked, what she thought the most excellent way to walk
in, and what were its chief hinderances.  She answered: `The greatest
hinderance is generally from the natural constitution.  It was mine to
be reserved, to be very quiet, to suffer much, and to say little.  Some
may think one way more excellent, and some another: But the thing is to
live in the will of God.  For some months past, when I have been
particularly devoted to this, I have felt such a guidance of his Spirit,
and the unction which I have received from the Holy One has so taught me
of all things, that I needed not any man should teach me, save as this
anointing teacheth.’

“(6.)  On Friday morning she said, `I believe I shall die.’  She then
sat up in her bed and said, `Lord, I bless thee, that thou art ever with
me, and all thou hast is mine.  Thy love is greater than my weakness,
greater than my helplessness, greater than my unworthiness.  Lord, thou
sayest +to corruption, Thou art my sister!+ And glory be to thee, O
Jesus, thou art my Brother.  Let me comprehend, with all saints, the
length, and breadth, and depth, and height of thy love!  Bless these;’
(some that were present;) `let them be every moment exercised in all
things as thou wouldest have them to be.’

“(7.)  Some hours after, it seemed as if the agonies of death were just
coming upon her; but her face was full of smiles of triumph, and she
clapped her hands for joy.  Mrs C. said, `My dear, you are more than
conqueror through the blood of the Lamb.’  She answered: ‘Yes, O yes,
sweet Jesus!  O death, where is thy sting?’  She then lay as in a doze
for some time.  Afterwards, she strove to speak, but could not: However,
she testified her love, by shaking hands with all in the room.

“(8.)  Mr.  W. then came.  She said, `Sir, I did not know that I should
live to see you.  But I am glad the Lord has given me this opportunity,
and likewise power to speak to you.  I love you.  You `have always
preached the strictest doctrine; and I loved to follow it.  Do so still,
whoever is pleased or displeased.’  He asked, `Do you now believe you
are saved from sin?’  She said, `Yes; I have had no doubt of it for many
months.  That I ever had, was, because I did not abide in the faith.  I
now feel I have kept the faith; and perfect love casteth out all fear.
As to you, the Lord promised me, your latter works should exceed your
former, though I do not live to see it.  I have been a great enthusiast,
as they term it, these six months; but never lived so near the heart of
Christ in my life.  You, Sir, desire to comfort the hearts of hundreds
by following that simplicity your soul loves.’

“(9.)  To one who had received the love of God under her prayer, she
said, `I feel I have not followed a cunningly-devised fable; for I am as
happy as I can live.  Do you press on, and stop not short of the mark.’
To Miss M—s she said, `Love Christ; he loves you.  I believe I shall
see you at the right hand of God: But +as one star differs from another
star in glory, so shall it be in the resurrection.+ I charge you, in the
presence of God, meet me in that day all-glorious within.  Avoid all
conformity to the world.  You are robbed of many’ of your privileges.  I
know I shall be found blameless.  Do you labour to be found of him +in
peace, without spot.’+

“(10.)  Saturday morning, she prayed nearly as follows: `I know, my
Lord, my life is prolonged only to do thy will.  And though I should
never eat or drink more,’ (she had not swallowed anything for near eight
-and-twenty hours,) `thy will be done.  I am willing to be kept so a
twelvemonth: +Man liveth not by bread alone.+ I praise thee that there
is not a shadow of complaining in our streets.  In that sense we know
not what sickness means.  Indeed, Lord, +neither life, nor death, nor
things present, nor things to come, no, nor any creature, shall separate
us from thy love one moment.  Bless these, that there may be no lack in
their souls.  I believe there shall not.  I pray in faith.’

“On Sunday and Monday she was light-headed, but sensible at times.  It
then plainly appeared, her heart was still in heaven.  One said to her,
`Jesus is our mark.’  She replied: `I have but one mark; I am all
spiritual.’  Miss M. said to her, `You dwell in God.’  She answered:
`Altogether.’  A person asked her: `Do you love me?’  She said, `O, I
love Christ; I love my Christ.’  To another she said, `I shall not long
be here; Jesus is precious, very precious indeed.’  She said to Miss M.,
`The Lord is very good; he keeps my soul above all.’  For fifteen hours
before she died, she was in strong convulsions: Her sufferings were
extreme.  One said, `You are made perfect through sufferings.’  She
said, `More and more so.’  After lying quiet some time, she said, `Lord,
thou art strong!’  Then pausing a considerable space, she uttered her
last words, `My Jesus is all in all to me: Glory be to him through time
and eternity.’  After this, she lay still for about half an hour, and
then expired without a sigh or groan.”

25.  The next year, the number of those who believed they were saved
from sin still increasing, I judged it needful to publish, chiefly for
their use, “Farther Thoughts on Christian Perfection:” —

“QUESTION 1.  How is `Christ the end of the law for righteousness to
every one that believeth?’  (Rom.  10:4.)

“ANSWER. In order to understand this, you must understand what law is
here spoken of; and this, I apprehend, is, (1.)  The Mosaic law, the
whole Mosaic dispensation; which St.  Paul continually speaks of as one,
though containing three parts, the political, moral, and ceremonial.
(2.)  The Adamic law, that given to Adam in innocence, properly called
`the law of works.’  This is in substance the same with the angelic law,
being common to angels and men.  It required that man should use, to the
glory of God, all the powers with which he was created.  Now, he was
created free from any defect, either in his understanding or his
affections.  His body was then no clog to the mind; it did not hinder
his apprehending all things clearly, judging truly concerning them, and
reasoning justly, if he reasoned at all.  I say, +if he reasoned;+ for
possibly he did not.  Perhaps he had no need of reasoning, till his
corruptible body pressed down the mind, and impaired its native
faculties.  Perhaps, till then, the mind saw every truth that offered as
directly as the eye now sees the light.

“Consequently, this law, proportioned to his original powers, required
that he should always think, always speak, and always act precisely
right, in every point whatever.  He was well able so to do: And God
could not but require the service he was able to pay.

“But Adam fell; and his incorruptible body became corruptible; and ever
since, it is a clog to the soul, and hinders its operations.  Hence, at
present, no child of man can at all times apprehend clearly, or judge
truly.  And where either the judgment or apprehension is wrong, it is
impossible to reason justly.  Therefore, it is as natural for a man to
mistake as to breathe; and he can no more live without the one than
without the other: Consequently, no man is able to perform the service
which the Adamic law requires.

“And no man is obliged to perform it; God does not require it of any
man: For Christ is the end of the Adamic, as well as the Mosaic, law.
By his death, he hath put an end to both; he hath abolished both the one
and the other, with regard to man; and the obligation to observe either
the one or the other is vanished away.  Nor is any man living bound to
observe the Adamic more than the Mosaic law.  [I mean, it is not the
condition either of present or future salvation.]

“In the room of this, Christ hath established another, namely, the law
of faith.  Not every one that doeth, but every one that believeth, now
receiveth righteousness, in the full sense of the word; that is, he is
justified, sanctified, and glorified.

“Q. 2.  Are we then dead to the law?

“A. We are `dead to the law, by the body of Christ’ given for us; (Rom.
7:4;) to the Adamic as well as Mosaic law.  We are wholly freed
therefrom by his death; that law expiring with him.

“Q. 3.  How, then, are we `not without law to God, but under the law to
Christ?’  (1 Cor.  9:21.)

“A. We are without that law; but it does not follow that we are without
any law: For God has established another law in its place, even the law
of faith: And we are all under this law to God and to Christ; both our
Creator and our Redeemer require us to observe it.

“Q. 4.  Is love the fulfilling of this law?

“A. Unquestionably it is.  The whole law under which we now are, is
fulfilled by love.  (Rom.  13:9, 10.)  Faith working or animated by love
is all that God now requires of man.  He has substituted (not sincerity,
but) love, in the room of angelic perfection.

“Q. 5.  How is `love the end of the commandment?’  (1 Tim.  1:5.)

“A. It is the end of every commandment of God.  It is the point aimed
at by the whole and every part of the Christian institution.  The
foundation is faith, purifying the heart; the end love, preserving a
good conscience.

“Q. 6.  What love is this?

“A. The loving the Lord our God with all our heart, mind, soul, and
strength; and the loving our neighbour, every man, as ourselves, as our
own souls.

“Q. 7.  What are the fruits or properties of this love?

“A. St.  Paul informs us at large, love is long-suffering.  It suffers
all the weaknesses of the children of God, all the wickedness of the
children of the world; and that not for a little’ time only, but as long
as God pleases.  In all, it sees the hand of God, and willingly submits
thereto.  Meantime, it is kind.  In all, and after all, it suffers, it
is soft, mild, tender, benign.  `Love envieth not;’ it excludes every
kind and degree of envy out of the heart: `love acteth not rashly,’ in a
violent, headstrong manner, nor passes any rash or severe judgment: It
`doth not behave itself indecently;’ is not rude, does not act out of
character: `Seeketh not her own’ ease, pleasure, honour, or profit: `Is
not provoked;’ expels all anger from the heart: `Thinketh no evil;’
casteth out all jealousy, suspiciousness, and readiness to believe evil:
`Rejoiceth not in iniquity;’ yea, weeps at the sin or folly of its
bitterest enemies: `But rejoiceth in the truth;’ in the holiness and
happiness of every child of man.  `Love covereth all things,’ speaks
evil of no man; `believeth all things’ that tend to the advantage of
another’s character.  It `hopeth all things,’ whatever may extenuate the
faults which cannot be denied; and it `endureth all things’ which God
can permit, or men and devils inflict.  This is `the law of Christ, the
perfect law, the law of liberty.’

“And this distinction between the `law of faith’ (or love) and `the law
of works,’ is neither a subtle nor `an unnecessary distinction.  It is
plain, easy, and intelligible to any common understanding.  And it is
absolutely necessary, to prevent a thousand doubts and fears, even in
those who do `walk in love.’

“Q. 8.  But do we not `in many things offend all,’ yea, the best of us,
even against this law?

“A. In one sense we do not, while all our tempers, and thoughts, and
words, and works, spring from love.  But in another we do, and shall do,
more or less, as long as we remain in the body.  For neither love nor
the `unction of the Holy One’ makes us infallible: Therefore, through
unavoidable defect of understanding, we cannot but mistake in many
things.  And these mistakes will frequently occasion something wrong,
both in our temper, and words, and actions.  From mistaking his
character, we may love a person less than he really deserves.  And by
the same mistake we are unavoidably led to speak or act, with regard to
that person, in such a manner as is contrary to this law, in some or
other of the preceding instances.

“Q. 9.  Do we not then need Christ, even on this account?

“A. The holiest of men still need Christ, as their Prophet, as `the
light of the world.’  For he does not give them light, but from moment
to moment: The instant he withdraws, all is darkness.  They still need
Christ as their King; for God does not give them a stock of holiness.
But unless they receive a supply every moment, nothing but unholiness
would remain.  They still need Christ as their Priest, to make atonement
for their holy things.  Even perfect holiness is acceptable to God only
through Jesus Christ.

‘ Q. 10.  May not, then, the very best of men adopt the dying Martyr’s
confession: `I am in myself nothing but sin, darkness, hell; but thou
art my light, my holiness, my heaven?’

“A. Not exactly.  But the best of men may say, `Thou art my light, my
holiness, my heaven.  Through my union with thee, I am full of light, of
holiness, and happiness.  But if I were left to myself, I should be
nothing but sin, darkness, hell.’

“But to proceed: The best of men need Christ as their Priest, their
Atonement, their Advocate with the Father; not only as the continuance
of their every blessing depends on his death and intercession, but on
account of their coming short of the law of love.  For every man living
does so.  You who feel all love, compare yourselves with the preceding
description.  Weigh yourselves in this balance, and see if you are not
wanting in many particulars.

“Q. 11.  But if all this be consistent with Christian perfection, that
perfection is not freedom from all sin; seeing sin is the transgression
of the law:’ And the perfect transgress the very law they are under.
Besides, they need the atonement of Christ; and he is the atonement of
nothing but sin.  Is, then, the term +sinless perfection,+ proper?

“A. It is not worth disputing about.  But observe in what sense the
persons in question need the atonement of Christ.  They do not need him
to reconcile them to God afresh; for they are reconciled.  They do not
need him to restore the favour of God, but to continue it.  He does not
procure pardon for them anew, but `ever liveth to make intercession for
them;’ and `by one offering he hath perfected for ever them that are
sanctified.’  (Heb.  10:14.)

“For want of duly considering this, some deny that they need the
atonement of Christ.  Indeed, exceeding few; I do not remember to have
found five of them in England.  Of the two, I would sooner give up
perfection; but we need not give up either one or the other.  The
perfection I hold, `Love rejoicing evermore, praying without ceasing,
and in everything giving thanks,’ is well consistent with it; if any
hold a perfection which is not, they must look to it.

“Q. 12.  Does then Christian perfection imply any more than sincerity?

“A. Not if you mean by that word, love filling the heart, expelling
pride, anger, desire, self-will; rejoicing evermore, praying without
ceasing, and in everything giving thanks.  But I doubt, few use
sincerity in this sense.  Therefore, I think the old word is best.

“A person may be sincere who has all his natural tempers, pride, anger,
lust, self-will.  But he is not perfect till his heart is cleansed from
these, and all its other corruptions.

“To clear this point a little farther: I know many that love God with
all their heart.  He is their one desire, their one delight, and they
are continually happy in him.  They love their neighbour as themselves.
They feel as sincere, fervent, constant a desire for the happiness of
every man, good or bad, friend or enemy, as for their own.  They rejoice
evermore, pray without ceasing, and in everything give thanks.  Their
souls are continually streaming up to God, in holy joy, prayer, and
praise.  This is a point of fact; and this is plain, sound, scriptural
experience.

“But even these souls dwell in a shattered body, and are so pressed
down thereby, that they cannot always exert themselves as they would, by
thinking, speaking, and acting precisely right.  For want of better
bodily organs, they must times think, speak, or act wrong; not indeed
through a defect of love, but through a defect of knowledge.  And while
this is the case, notwithstanding that defect, and its consequences,
they fulfil the law of love.

“Yet as, even in this case, there is not a full conformity to the
perfect law, so the most perfect do, on this very account, need the
blood of atonement, and may properly for themselves, as well as for
their brethren, say, `Forgive us our trespasses.’

“Q. 13.  But if Christ has put an end to that law, what need of any
atonement for their transgressing it?

“A. Observe in what sense he has put an end to it, and the difficulty
vanishes.  Were it not for the abiding merit of his death, and his
continual intercession for us, that law would condemn us still.  These,
therefore, we still need for every transgression of it.

“Q. 14.  But can one that is saved from sin be tempted?

“A. Yes; for Christ was tempted.

“Q. 15.  However, what you call temptation, I call the corruption of my
heart.  And how will you distinguish one from the other?

“A. In some cases it is impossible to distinguish, without the direct
witness of the Spirit.  But in general one may distinguish thus: —

“One commends me.  Here is a temptation to pride.  But instantly my
soul is humbled before God.  And I feel no pride; of which I am as sure,
as that pride is not humility.

“A man strikes me.  Here is a temptation to anger.  But my heart
overflows with love.  And I feel no anger at all; of which I can be as
sure, as that love and anger are not the same.

“A woman solicits me.  Here is a temptation to lust.  But in the
instant I shrink back.  And I feel no desire or lust at all; of which I
can be as sure, as that my hand is cold or hot.

“Thus it is, if I am tempted by a present object; and it is just the
same, if; when it is absent, the devil recals a commendation, an injury,
or a woman, to my mind.  In the instant the soul repels the temptation,
and remains filled with pure love.

“And the difference is still plainer, when I compare my present state
with my past, wherein I felt temptation and corruption too.

“Q. 16.  But how do you know, that you are sanctified, saved from your
inbred corruption?

“A. I can know it no otherwise than I know that I am justified.
`Hereby know we that we are of God,’ in either sense, `by the Spirit
that he hath given us.’

“We know it by the witness and by the fruit of the Spirit.  And, First,
by the witness.  As, when we were justified, the Spirit bore witness
with our spirit, that our sins were forgiven; so, when we were
sanctified, he bore witness, that they were taken away.  Indeed, the
witness of sanctification is not always clear at first; (as neither is
that of justification;) neither is it afterward always the same, but,
like that of justification, sometimes stronger and sometimes fainter.
Yea, and sometimes it is withdrawn.  Yet, in general, the latter
testimony of the Spirit is both as clear and as steady as the former.

“Q. 17.  But what need is there of it, seeing sanctification is a real
change, not a relative only, like justification?

“A. But is the new birth a relative change only?  Is not this a real
change?  Therefore, if we need no witness of our sanctification, because
it is a real change, for the same reason we should need none, that we
are born of or are the children of God.

“Q. 18.  But does not sanctification shine by its own light?

“A. And does not the new birth too?  Sometimes it does; and so does
sanctification; at others it does not.  In the hour of temptation Satan
clouds the work of God, and injects various doubts and reasonings,
especially in those who have either very weak or very strong
understandings.  At such times there is absolute need of that witness;
without which the work of sanctification not only could not be
discerned, but could no longer subsist.  Were it not for this, the soul
could not then abide in the love of God; much less could it rejoice
evermore, and in everything give thanks.  In these circumstances,
therefore, a direct testimony that we are sanctified is necessary in the
highest degree.

“`But I have no witness that I am saved from sin.  And yet I have no
doubt of it.’  Very well: As long as you have no doubt, it is enough;
when you have, you will need that witness.

“Q. 19.  But what scripture makes mention of any such thing, or gives
any reason to expect it?

“A. That scripture, `We have received, not the spirit that is of the
world, but the Spirit which is of God; that we may know the things which
are freely given us of God.’  (1 Cor.  2:12.)

“Now surely sanctification is one of `the things which are freely given
us of God.’  And no possible reason can be assigned why this should be
excepted, when the Apostle says, `We receive the Spirit’ for this very
end, `that we may know the things which are’ thus `freely given us.’

“Is not the same thing implied in that well-known scripture, `The
Spirit itself witnesseth with our spirit, that we are the children of
God?’  (Romans 8:16.)  Does he witness this only to those who are
children of God in the lowest sense?  Nay, but to those also who are
such in the highest sense.  And does he not witness, that they are such
in the highest sense?  What reason have we to doubt it?

“What, if a man were to affirm, (as indeed many do,) that this witness
belongs only to the highest class of Christians?  Would not you answer,
`The Apostle makes no restriction; therefore doubtless it belongs to all
the children of God?’  And will not the same answer hold, if any affirm,
that it belongs only to the lowest class?

“Consider likewise 1 John 5:19: `We know that we are of God.’  How?
`By the Spirit that he hath given us.’  Nay, `hereby we know that He
abideth in us.  And what ground have we, either from Scripture or
reason, to exclude the witness, any more than the fruit, of the Spirit,
from being here intended?  By this then also `we know that we are of
God,’ and in what sense we are so; whether we are babes, young men, or
fathers, we know in the same manner.

“Not that I affirm that all young men, or even fathers, have this
testimony every moment.  There may be intermissions of the direct
testimony that they are thus born of God; but those intermissions are
fewer and shorter as they grow up in Christ; and some have the testimony
both of their justification and sanctification, without any intermission
at all; which I presume more might have, did they walk humbly and
closely with God.

“Q. 20.  May not some of them have a testimony from the Spirit, that
they shall not finally fall from God?

“A. They may.  And this persuasion, that neither life nor death shall
separate them from Him, far from being hurtful, may in some
circumstances be extremely useful.  These therefore we should in nowise
grieve, but earnestly encourage them to `hold the beginning of their
confidence steadfast to the end.’

“Q. 21.  But have any a testimony from the Spirit that they shall never
sin?

“A. We know not what God `nay vouchsafe to some particular persons; but
we do not find any general state described in Scripture, from which a
man cannot draw back to sin.  If there were any state wherein this was
impossible, it would be that of these who are sanctified, who are
`fathers in Christ, who rejoice evermore, pray without ceasing, and in
every thing give thanks;’ but it is not impossible for these to draw
back.  They who are sanctified, yet may fall and perish.  (Heb.  10:29.)
Even fathers in Christ need that warning: `Love not the world.’  (1 John
2:15.)  They who `rejoice, pray,’ and `give thanks without ceasing,’
may, nevertheless, `quench the Spirit.’  (1 Thess.  5:16, &c.)  Nay,
even they who are `sealed unto the day of redemption,’ may yet `grieve
the Holy Spirit of God.’  (Ephesians 4:30.)

“Although, therefore, God may give such a witness to some particular
persons, yet it is not to be expected by Christians in general; there
being no scripture whereon to ground such an expectation.

“Q. 22.  By what `fruit of the Spirit’ may we `know that we are of
God,’ even in the highest sense?

“A. By love, joy, peace, always abiding; by invariable long-suffering,
patience, resignation; by gentleness, triumphing over all provocation;
by goodness, mildness, sweetness, tenderness of spirit; by fidelity,
simplicity, godly sincerity; by meekness, calmness, evenness of spirit;
by temperance, not only in food and sleep, but in all things natural and
spiritual.

“Q. 23.  But what great matter is there in this?  Have we not all this
when we are justified?

“A. What, total resignation to the will of God, without any mixture of
self-will?  gentleness, without any touch of anger, even the moment we
are provoked?  love to God, without the least love to the creature, but
in and for God, excluding all pride?  love to man, excluding all envy,
all jealousy, and rash judging?  meekness, keeping the whole soul
inviolably calm?  and temperance in all things?  Deny that any ever came
up to this, if you please; but do not say, all who are justified do.

“Q. 24.  But some who are newly justified do.  What then will you say
to these?

“A. If they really do, I will say they are sanctified; saved from sin
in that moment; and that they never need lose what God has given, or
feel sin any more.

“But certainly this is an exempt case.  It is otherwise with the
generality of those that are justified: They feel in themselves more or
less pride, anger, self-will, a heart bent to backsliding.  And, till
they have gradually mortified these, they are not fully renewed in love.

“Q. 25.  But is not this the case of all that are justified?  Do they
not gradually die to sin and grow in grace, till at, or perhaps a little
before, death God perfects them in love?

“A. I believe this is the case of most, but not all.  God usually gives
a considerable time for men to receive light, to grow in grace, to do
and suffer his will, before they are either justified or sanctified; but
he does not invariably adhere to this; sometimes he `cuts short his
work:’ he does the work of many years in a few weeks; perhaps in a week,
a day, an hour.  He justifies or sanctifies both those who have done or
suffered nothing, and who have not had time for a gradual growth either
in light or grace.  And `may he not do what he will with his own?  Is
thine eye evil, because he is good?’

“It need not, therefore, be affirmed over and over, and proved by forty
texts of Scripture, either that most men are perfected in love at last,
that there is a gradual work of God in the soul, or that, generally
speaking, it is a long time, even many years, before sin is destroyed.
All this we know: But we know likewise, that God may, with man’s good
leave, `cut short his work,’ in whatever degree he pleases, and do the
usual work of many years in a moment.  He does so in many instances; and
yet there is a gradual work, both before and after that moment: So that
one may affirm the work is gradual, another, it is instantaneous,
without any manner of contradiction.

“Q. 26.  Does St.  Paul mean any more by being `sealed with the
Spirit,’ than being `renewed in love?’

“A. Perhaps in one place, (2 Cor.  1:22,) he does not mean so much; but
in another, (Eph.  1:13,) he seems to include both the fruit and the
witness; and that in a higher degree than we experience even when we are
first `renewed in love;’ God `sealeth us with the Spirit of promise,’ by
giving us `the full assurance of hope;’ such a confidence of receiving
all the promises of God, as excludes the possibility of doubting; with
that Holy Spirit, by universal holiness, stamping the whole image of God
on our hearts.

“Q. 27.  But how can those who are thus sealed `grieve the Holy Spirit
of God?’

“A. St.  Paul tells you very particularly, (1.)  By such conversation
as is not profitable, not to the use of edifying, not apt to minister
grace to the hearers.  (2.)  By relapsing into bitterness or want of
kindness.  (3.)  By wrath, lasting displeasure, or want of tender-
heartedness.  (4.)  By anger, however soon it is over; want of instantly
forgiving one another.  (5.)  By clamour or bawling, loud, harsh, rough
speaking.  (6.)  By evil-speaking, whispering, tale-bearing; needlessly
mentioning the fault of an absent person, though in ever so soft a
manner.

“Q. 28.  What do you think of those in London, who seem to have been
lately `renewed in love?’

“A. There is something very peculiar in the experience of the greater
part of them.  One would expect that a believer should first be filled
with love, and thereby emptied of sin; whereas these were emptied of sin
first, and then filled with love.  Perhaps it pleased God to work in
this manner, to make his work more plain and undeniable; and to
distinguish it more clearly from that overflowing love, which is often
felt even in a justified state.

“It seems likewise most agreeable to the great promise: `From all your
filthiness I will cleanse you; a new heart also will I give you, and a
new spirit will I put within you.’  (Ezek.  36:25, 26.)

“But I do not think of them all alike: There is a wide difference
between some of them and others.  I think most of them with whom I have
spoken, have much faith, love, joy, and peace.  Some of these I believe
are renewed in love, and have the direct witness of it; and they
manifest the fruit above described, in all their words and actions.
Now, let any man call this what he will; it is what I call perfection.

“But some who have much love, peace, and joy, yet have not the direct
witness; and others who think they have, are, nevertheless, manifestly
wanting in the fruit.  How many I will not say; perhaps one in ten;
perhaps more or fewer.  But some are undeniably wanting in
longsuffering, Christian resignation.  They do not see the hand of God
in whatever occurs, and cheerfully embrace it.  They do not in
everything give thanks, and rejoice evermore.  They are not happy; at
least, not always happy; for sometimes they complain.  They say, this or
that is hard!

“Some are wanting in gentleness.  They resist evil, instead of turning
the other cheek.  They do not receive reproach with gentleness; no, nor
even reproof.  Nay, they are not able to bear contradiction, without the
appearance, at least, of resentment.  If they are reproved or
contradicted, though mildly, they do not take it well; they behave with
more distance and reserve than they did before.  If they are reproved or
contradicted harshly, they answer it with harshness; with a loud voice,
or with an angry tone, or in a sharp and surly manner.  They speak
sharply or roughly, when they reprove others; and behave roughly to
their inferiors.

“Some are wanting in goodness.  They are not kind, mild, sweet,
amiable, soft, and loving at all times, in their spirit, in their words,
in their look and air, in the whole tenor of their behaviour; and that
to all, high and low, rich and poor, without respect of persons;
particularly to them that are out of the way, to opposers, and to those
of their own household.  They do not long, study, endeavour by every
means, to make all about them happy.  They can see them uneasy, and not
be concerned; perhaps they make them so; and then wipe their mouths and
say, `Why, they deserve it; it is their own fault.’

“Some are wanting in fidelity, a nice regard to truth, simplicity, and
godly sincerity.  Their love is hardly without dissimulation; something
like guile is found in their mouth.  To avoid roughness, they lean to
the other extreme.  They are smooth to an excess, so as scarce to avoid
a degree of fawning, or of seeming to mean what they do not.

“Some are wanting in meekness, quietness of spirit, composure, evenness
of temper.  They are up and down, sometimes high, sometimes low; their
mind is not well balanced.  Their affections are either not in due
proportion; they have too much of one, too little of another; or they
are not duly mixed and tempered together, so as to counterpoise each
other.  Hence there is often a jar.  Their soul is out of tune, and
cannot make the true harmony.

“Some are wanting in temperance.  They do not steadily use that kind
and degree of food, which they know, or might know, would most conduce
to the health strength, and vigour of the body: Or they are not
temperate in sleep; they do not rigorously adhere to what is best both
for body and mind; otherwise they would constantly go to bed and rise
early, and at a fixed hour: Or they sup late, which is neither good for
body nor soul: Or they use neither fasting nor abstinence: Or they
prefer (which are so many sorts of intemperance) that preaching,
reading, or conversation, which gives them transient joy and comfort,
before that which brings godly sorrow, or instruction in righteousness.
Such joy is not sanctified; it doth not tend to, and terminate in, the
crucifixion of the heart.  Such faith doth not centre in God, but rather
in itself.

“So far all is plain.  I believe you have faith, and love, and joy, and
peace.  Yet you who are particularly concerned know each for yourself,
that you are wanting in the respects above-mentioned.  You are wanting
either in long-suffering, gentleness, or goodness; either in fidelity,
meekness, or temperance.  Let us not, then, on either hand, fight about
words.  In the thing we clearly agree.

“You have not what I call perfection; if others will call it so, they
may.  However, hold fast what you have, and earnestly pray for what you
have not.

“Q. 29.  Can those who are perfect grow in grace?

“A. Undoubtedly they can; and that not only while they are in the body,
but to all eternity.

“Q. 30.  Can they fall from it?

“A. I am well assured they can; matter of fact puts this beyond
dispute.  Formerly we thought, one saved from sin could not fall; now we
know the contrary.  We are surrounded with instances of those who lately
experienced all that I mean by perfection.  They had both the fruit of
the Spirit, and the witness; but they have now lost both.  Neither does
any one stand by virtue of anything that is implied in the nature of the
state.  There is no such height or strength of holiness as it is
impossible to fall from.  If there be any that cannot fall, this wholly
depends on the promise of God.

“Q. 31.  Can those who fall from this state recover it?

“A. Why not?  We have many instances of this also.  Nay, it is an
exceeding common thing for persons to lose it more than once, before
they are established therein.

“It is therefore to guard them who are saved from sin, from every
occasion of stumbling, that I give the following advices.  But first I
shall speak plainly concerning the work itself.

“I esteem this late work to be of God; probably the greatest now upon
earth.  Yet, like all others, this also is mixed with much human
frailty.  But these weaknesses are far less than might have been
expected; and ought to have been joyfully borne by all that loved and
followed after righteousness.  That there have been a few weak, warm-
headed men, is no reproach to the work itself, no just ground for
accusing a multitude of sober-minded men, who are patterns of strict
holiness.  Yet (just the contrary to what ought to have been) the
opposition is great; the helps few.  Hereby many are hindered from
seeking faith and holiness by the false zeal of others; and some who at
first began to run well are turned out of the way.

“Q. 32.  What is the First advice [The advices which follow were
published in a separate tract in the year 1762, under the title of
“Cautions and Directions given to the Greatest Professors in the
Methodist Societies,” with the following motto: —

“Set the false witnesses aside, Yet hold the truth for ever fast.”

It was evidently intended to guard the people against the mischievous
extravagances of George Bell and his friends, a particular account of
whom is given in Mr.  Wesley’s Journal about that period.  — EDIT.]
that you would give them?

“A. Watch and pray continually against pride.  If God has cast it out,
see that it enter no more: It is full as dangerous as desire.  And you
may slide back into it unawares; especially if you think there is no
danger of it.  `Nay, but I ascribe all I have to God.’  So you may, and
be proud nevertheless.  For it is pride, not only to ascribe anything we
have to ourselves, but to think we have what we really have not.  Mr.  L
—, for instance, ascribed all the light he had to God, and so far he
was humble; but then he thought he had more light than any man living;
and this was palpable pride.  So you ascribe all the knowledge you have
to God; and in this respect you are humble.  But if you think you have
more than you really have; or if you think you are so taught of God, as
no longer to need man’s teaching; pride lieth at the door.  Yes; you
have need to be taught, not only by Mr.  Morgan, by one another, by Mr.
Maxfield, or me, but by the weakest Preacher in London; yea, by all men.
For God sendeth by whom he will send.

“Do not therefore say to any who would advise or reprove you, `You are
blind; you cannot teach me.’  Do not say, `This is your wisdom, your
carnal reason;’ but calmly weigh the thing before God.

“Always remember, much grace does not imply much light.  These do not
always go together.  As there may be much light where there is but
little love, so there may be much love where there is little light.  The
heart has more heat than the eye; yet it cannot see.  And God has wisely
tempered the members of the body together, that none may say to another,
`I have no need of thee.’

“To imagine none can teach you, but those who are themselves saved from
sin, is a very great and dangerous mistake.  Give not place to it for a
moment; it would lead you into a thousand other mistakes, and that
irrecoverably.  No; dominion is not founded in grace, as the madmen of
the last age talked.  Obey and regard `them that are over you in the
Lord,’ and do not think you know better than them.  Know their place and
your own; always remembering, much love does not imply much light.

“The not observing this has led some into many mistakes, and into the
appearance, at least, of pride.  O beware of the appearance, and the
thing!  Let there `be in you that lowly mind which was in Christ Jesus.’
And.  `be ye likewise clothed with humility.’  Let it not only fill, but
cover you all over.  Let modesty and self-diffidence appear in all your
words and actions.  Let all you speak and do show that you are little,
and base, and mean, and vile in your own eyes.

“As one instance of this, be always ready to own any fault you have
been in.  If you have at any time thought, spoke, or acted wrong, be not
backward to acknowledge it.  Never dream that this will hurt the cause
of God; no, it will further it.  Be therefore open and frank, when you
are taxed with anything; do not seek either to evade or disguise it; but
let it appear just as it is, and you will thereby not hinder, but adorn,
the gospel.

“Q. 33.  What is the Second advice which you would give them?

“A. Beware of that daughter of pride, enthusiasm.  O keep at the utmost
distance from it!  Give no place to a heated imagination.  Do not
hastily ascribe things to God.  Do not easily suppose dreams, voices,
impressions, visions, or revelations to be from God.  They may be from
him.  They may be from nature.  They may be from the devil.  Therefore,
`believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they be of God.’
Try all things by the written word, and let all bow down before it.  You
are in danger of enthusiasm every hour, if you depart ever so little
from Scripture; yea, or from the plain, literal meaning of any text,
taken in connexion with the context.  And so you are, if you despise or
lightly esteem reason, knowledge, or human learning; every one of which
is an excellent gift of God, and may serve the noblest purposes.

“I advise you, never to use the words, wisdom, reason, or knowledge, by
way of reproach.  On the contrary, pray that you yourself may abound in
them more and more.  If you mean worldly wisdom, useless knowledge,
false reasoning, say so; and throw away the chaff, but not the wheat.

“One general inlet to enthusiasm is, expecting the end without the
means; the expecting knowledge, for instance, without searching the
Scriptures, and consulting the children of God; the expecting spiritual
strength without constant prayer, and steady watchfulness; the expecting
any blessing without hearing the word of God at every opportunity.

“Some have been ignorant of this device of Satan.  They have left off
searching the Scriptures.  They said, `God writes all the Scriptures on
my heart.  Therefore, I have no need to read it.’  Others thought they
had not so much need of hearing, and so grew slack in attending the
morning preaching.  O take warning, you who are concerned herein!  You
have listened to the voice of a stranger.  Fly back to Christ, and keep
in the good old way, which was `once delivered to the saints;’ the way
that even a Heathen bore testimony of: `That the Christians rose early
every day to sing hymns to Christ as God.’

“The very desire of `growing in grace’ may sometimes be an inlet of
enthusiasm.  As it continually leads us to seek new grace, it may lead
us unawares to seek something else new, beside new degrees of love to
God and man.  So it has led some to seek and fancy they had received
gifts of a new kind, after a new heart, as, (1.)  The loving God with
all our mind; (2.)  With all our soul; (3.)  With all our strength: (4.)
Oneness with God: (5.)  Oneness with Christ: (6.)  Having our life hid
with Christ in God: (7.)  Being dead with Christ: (8.)  Rising with him:
(9.)  The sitting with him in heavenly places: (10.)  The being taken up
into his throne: (11.)  The being in the New Jerusalem: (12.)  The
seeing the tabernacle of God come down among men: (13.)  The being dead
to all works: (14.)  The not being liable to death, pain, or grief, or
temptation.

“One ground of many of these mistakes is, the taking every fresh,
strong application of any of these scriptures to the heart, to be a gift
of a new kind; not knowing that several of these scriptures are not
fulfilled yet; that most of the others are fulfilled when we are
justified; the rest, the moment we are sanctified.  It remains only to
experience them in higher degrees.  This is all we have to expect.

“Another ground of these, and a thousand mistakes, is, the not
considering deeply, that love is the highest gift of God; humble,
gentle, patient love; that all visions, revelations, manifestations
whatever, are little things compared to love; and that all the gifts
above-mentioned are either the same with, or infinitely inferior to, it.

“It were well you should be thoroughly sensible of this, — `the heaven
of heavens is love.’  There is nothing higher in religion; there is, in
effect, nothing else; if you look for anything but more love, you are
looking wide of the mark, you are getting out of the royal way.  And
when you are asking others, `Have you received this or that blessing?’
if you mean anything but more love, you mean wrong; you are leading them
out of the way, and putting them upon a false scent.  Settle it then in
your heart, that from the moment God has saved you from all sin, you are
to aim at nothing more, but more of that love described in the
thirteenth of the Corinthians.  [1 Cor.  13] You can go no higher than
this, till you are carried into Abraham’s bosom.

“I say yet again, beware of enthusiasm.  Such is, the imagining you
have the gift of prophesying, or of discerning of spirits, which I do
not believe one of you has; no, nor ever had yet.  Beware of judging
people to be either right or wrong by your own feelings.  This is no
scriptural way of judging.  O keep close to `the law and to the
testimony!’

“Q. 34.  What is the Third?

“A. Beware of Antinomianism; `making void the law,’ or any part of it,
`through faith.’  Enthusiasm naturally leads to this; indeed they can
scarce be separated.  This may steal upon you in a thousand forms, so
that you cannot be too watchful against it.  Take heed of everything,
whether in principle or practice, which has any tendency thereto.  Even
that great truth, that `Christ is the end of the law,’ may betray us
into it, if we do not consider that he has adopted every point of the
moral law, and grafted it into the law of love.  Beware of thinking,
`Because I am filled with love, I need not have so much holiness.
Because I pray always, therefore I need no set time for private prayer.
Because I watch always, therefore I need no particular self-
examination.’  Let us `magnify the law,’ the whole written word, `and
make it honourable.’  Let this be our voice: `I prize thy commandments
above gold or precious stones.  O what love have I unto thy law!  all
the day long is my study in it.’  Beware of Antinomian books;
particularly the works of Dr.  Crisp and Mr.  Saltmarsh.  They contain
many excellent things; and this makes them the more dangerous.  O be
warned in time!  Do not play with fire.  Do not put your hand on the
hole of a cockatrice’ den.  I entreat you, beware of bigotry.  Let not
your love or beneficence be confined to Methodists, so called, only;
much less to that very small part of them who seem to be renewed in
love; or to those who believe yours and their report.  O make not this
your Shibboleth!  Beware of stillness; ceasing in a wrong sense from
your own works.  To mention one instance out of many: `You have
received,’ says one, `a great blessing.  But you began to talk of it,
and to do this and that; so you lost it.  You should have been still.’

“Beware of self-indulgence; yea, and making a virtue of it, laughing at
self-denial, and taking up the cross daily, at fasting or abstinence.
Beware of censoriousness; thinking or calling them that anyways oppose
you, whether in judgment or practice, blind, dead, fallen, or `enemies
to the work.’  Once more, beware of Solifidianism; crying nothing but,
`Believe, believe!’  and condemning those as ignorant or legal who speak
in a more scriptural way.  At certain seasons, indeed, it may be right
to treat of nothing but repentance, or merely of faith, or altogether of
holiness; but, in general, our call is to declare the whole `counsel of
God, and to prophesy according to the analogy of faith.  The written
word treats of the whole and every particular branch of righteousness,
descending to its minutest branches; as to be sober, courteous,
diligent, patient, to honour all men.  So, likewise, the Holy Spirit
works the same in our hearts, not merely creating desires after holiness
in general, but strongly inclining us to every particular grace, leading
us to every individual part of `whatsoever is lovely.’  And this with
the greatest propriety: For as `by works faith is made perfect; so the
completing or destroying the work of faith, and enjoying the favour, or
suffering the displeasure, of God, greatly depends on every single act
of obedience or disobedience.

“Q. 35.  What is the Fourth?

“A. Beware of sins of omission; lose no opportunity of doing good in
any kind.  Be zealous of good works; willingly omit no work, either of
piety or mercy.  Do all the good you possibly can to the bodies and
souls of men.  Particularly, `thou shalt in anywise reprove thy
neighbour, and not suffer sin upon him.’  Be active.  Give no place to
indolence or sloth; give no occasion to say, `Ye are idle, ye are idle.’
Many will say so still; but let your whole spirit and behaviour refute
the slander.  Be always employed; lose no shred of time; gather up the
fragments, that nothing be lost.  And whatsoever thy hand findeth to do,
do it with thy might.  Be `slow to speak,’ and wary in speaking.  `In a
multitude of words there wanteth not sin.’  Do not talk much; neither
long at a time.  Few can converse profitably above an hour.  Keep at the
utmost distance from pious chit-chat, from religious gossiping.

“Q. 36.  What is the Fifth?

“A. Beware of desiring anything but God.  Now you desire nothing else;
every other desire is driven out; see that none enter again.  `Keep
thyself pure;’ let your `eye’ remain `single, and your whole body shall
be full of light.’  Admit no desire of pleasing food, or any other
pleasure of sense; no desire of pleasing the eye or the imagination, by
anything grand, or new, or beautiful; no desire of money, of praise, or
esteem; of happiness in any creature.  You may bring these desires back;
but you need not; you need feel them no more.  O stand fast in the
liberty wherewith Christ hath made you free.

“Be patterns to all, of denying yourselves, and taking up your cross
daily.  Let them see that you make no account of any pleasure which does
not bring you nearer to God, nor regard any pain which does; that you
simply aim at pleasing him, whether by doing or suffering; that the
constant language of your heart, with regard to pleasure or pain, honour
or dishonour, riches or poverty, is,

‘All’s alike to me, so I In my Lord may live and die!’

Q. 37.  What is the Sixth?

“A. Beware of schism, of making a rent in the Church of Christ.  That
inward disunion, the members ceasing to have a reciprocal love `one for
another,’ (1 Cor.  12:25,) is the very root of all contention, and every
outward separation.  Beware of everything tending thereto.  Beware of a
dividing spirit; shun whatever has the least aspect that way.
Therefore, say not, `I am of Paul or of Apollos;’ the very thing which
occasioned the schism at Corinth.  Say not, `This is my Preacher; the
best Preacher in England.  Give me him, and take all the rest.’  All
this tends to breed or foment division, to disunite those whom God hath
joined.  Do not despise or run down any Preacher; do not exalt any one
above the rest, lest you hurt both him and the cause of God.  On the
other hand, do not bear hard upon any by reason of some incoherency or
inaccuracy of expression; no, nor for some mistakes, were they really
such.

“Likewise, if you would avoid schism, observe every rule of the
Society, and of the Bands, for conscience’ sake.  Never omit meeting
your Class or Band; never absent yourself from any public meeting.
These are the very sinews of our Society; and whatever weakens, or tends
to weaken, our regard for these, or our exactness in attending them,
strikes at the very root of our community.  As one saith, `That part of
our economy, the private weekly meetings for prayer, examination, and
particular exhortation, has been the greatest means of deepening and
confirming every blessing that was received by the word preached, and of
diffusing it to others, who could not attend the public ministry;
whereas, without this religious connexion and intercourse, the most
ardent attempts, by mere preaching, have proved of no lasting use.’

“Suffer not one thought of separating from your brethren, whether their
opinions agree with yours or not.  Do not dream that any man sins in not
believing you, in not taking your word; or that this or that opinion is
essential to the work, and both must stand or fall together.  Beware of
impatience of contradiction.  Do not condemn or think hardly of those
who cannot see just as you see, or who judge it their duty to contradict
you, whether in a great thing or a small.  I fear some of us have
thought hardly of others, merely because they contradicted what we
affirmed.  All this tends to division; and, by everything of this kind,
we are teaching them an evil lesson against ourselves.

“O beware of touchiness, of testiness, not bearing to be spoken to;
starting at the least word; and flying from those who do not implicitly
receive mine or another’s sayings!

“Expect contradiction and opposition, together with crosses of various
kinds.  Consider the words of St.  Paul: `To you it is given, in the
behalf of Christ,’ — for his sake, as a fruit of his death and
intercession for you, — `not only to believe, but also to suffer for
his sake.’  (Phil.  1:29.)  +It is given!+ God gives you this opposition
or reproach; it is a fresh token of his love.  And will you disown the
Giver; or spurn his gift, and count it a misfortune?  Will you not
rather say, `Father, the hour is come, that thou shouldest be glorified:
Now thou givest thy child to suffer something for thee: Do with me
according to thy will?’  Know that these things, far from being
hinderances to the work of God, or to your soul, unless by your own
fault, are not only unavoidable in the course of Providence, but
profitable, yea, necessary, for you.  Therefore, receive them from God
(not from chance) with willingness, with thankfulness.  Receive them
from men with humility, meekness, yieldingness, gentleness, sweetness.
Why should not even your outward appearance and manner be soft?
Remember the character of Lady Cutts: `It was said of the Roman Emperor
Titus, Never any one came displeased from him.  But it might be said of
her, Never any one went displeased to her: So secure were all of the
kind and favourable reception which they would meet with from her.’

“Beware of tempting others to separate from you.  Give no offence which
can possibly be avoided; see that your practice be in all things
suitable to your profession, adorning the doctrine of God our Saviour.
Be particularly careful in speaking of yourself: You may not, indeed,
deny the work of God; but speak of it, when you are called thereto, in
the most inoffensive manner possible.  Avoid all magnificent, pompous
words; indeed, you need give it no general name; neither perfection,
sanctification, the second blessing, nor the having attained.  Rather
speak of the particulars which God has wrought for you.  You may say,
`At such a time I felt a change which I am not able to express; and
since that time, I have not felt pride, or self-will, or anger, or
unbelief; nor anything but a fulness of love to God and to all mankind.’
And answer any other plain question that is asked with modesty and
simplicity.

“And if any of you should at any time fall from what you now are, if
you should again feel pride or unbelief, or any temper from which you
are now delivered; do not deny, do not hide, do not disguise it at all,
at the peril of your soul.  At all events go to one in whom you can
confide, and speak just what you feel.  God will enable him to speak a
word in season, which shall be health to your soul.  And surely He will
again lift up your head, and cause the bones that have been broken to
rejoice.

“Q. 38.  What is the last advice that you would give them?

“A. Be exemplary in all things; particularly in outward things, (as in
dress,) in little things, in the laying out of your money, (avoiding
every needless expense,) in deep, steady seriousness, and in the
solidity and usefulness of all your conversation.  So shall you be `a
light shining in a dark place.’  So shall you daily `grow in grace,’
till `an entrance be ministered unto you abundantly into the everlasting
kingdom of our Lord Jesus Christ.’

“Most of the preceding advices are strongly enforced in the following
reflections; which I recommend to your deep and frequent consideration,
next to the holy Scriptures: —

“(1.)  The sea is an excellent figure of the fulness of God, and that
of the blessed Spirit.  For as the rivers all return into the sea; so
the bodies, the souls, and the good works of the righteous, return into
God, to live there in his eternal repose.

“Although all the graces of God depend on his mere bounty, yet is He
pleased generally to attach them to the prayers, the instructions, and
the holiness of those with whom we are.  By strong though invisible
attractions He draws some souls through their intercourse with others.

“The sympathies formed by grace far surpass those formed by nature.

“The truly devout show that passions as naturally flow from true as
from false love; so deeply sensible are they of the goods and evils of
those whom they love for God’s sake.  But this can only be comprehended
by those who understand the language of love.

“The bottom of the soul may be in repose, even while we are in many
outward troubles; just as the bottom of the sea is calm, while the
surface is strongly agitated.

“The best helps to growth in grace are the ill usage, the affronts, and
the losses which befal us.  We should receive them with all
thankfulness, as preferable to all others, were it only on this account,
— that our will has no part therein.

“The readiest way to escape from our sufferings is, to be willing they
should endure as long as God pleases.

“If we suffer persecution and affliction in a right manner, we attain a
larger measure of conformity to Christ, by a due improvement of one of
these occasions, than we could have done merely by imitating his mercy,
in abundance of good works.

“One of the greatest evidences of God’s love to those that love him is,
to send them afflictions, with grace to bear them.

“Even in the greatest afflictions, we ought to testify to God, that, in
receiving them from his hand, we feel pleasure in the midst of the pain,
from being afflicted by Him who loves us, and whom we love.

“The readiest way which God takes to draw a man to himself is, to
afflict him in that he loves most, and with good reason; and to cause
this affliction to arise from some good action done with a single eye;
because nothing can more clearly show him the emptiness of what is most
lovely and desirable in the world.

“(2.)  True resignation consists in a thorough conformity to the whole
will of God; who wills and does all (excepting sin) which comes to pass
in the world.  In order to this we have only to embrace all events, good
and bad, as His will.

“In the greatest afflictions which can befal the just, either from
heaven or earth, they remain immovable in peace, and perfectly
submissive to God, by an inward, loving regard to Him, uniting in one
all the powers of their souls.

“We ought quietly to suffer whatever befals us, to bear the defects of
others and our own, to confess them to God in secret prayer, or with
groans which cannot be uttered; but never to speak a sharp or peevish
word, nor to murmur or repine; but thoroughly willing that God should
treat you in the manner that pleases him.  We are his lambs, and
therefore ought to be ready to suffer, even to the death, without
complaining.

“We are to bear with those we cannot amend, and to be content with
offering them to God.  This is true resignation.  And since He has borne
our infirmities, we may well bear those of each other for His sake.

“To abandon all, to strip one’s self of all, in order to seek and to
follow Jesus Christ naked to Bethlehem, where he was born; naked to the
hall where he was scourged; and naked to Calvary, where he died on the
cross, is so great a mercy, that neither the thing, nor the knowledge of
it is given to any, but through faith in the Son of God.

“(3.)  There is no love of God without patience, and no patience
without lowliness and sweetness of spirit.

“Humility and patience are the surest proofs of the increase of love.

“Humility alone unites patience with love; without which it is
impossible to draw profit from suffering; or indeed, to avoid complaint,
especially when we think we have given no occasion for what men make us
suffer.

“True humility is a kind of self-annihilation; and this is the centre
of all virtues.

“A soul returned to God ought to be attentive to everything which is
said to him, on the head of salvation, with a desire to profit thereby.

“Of the sins which God has pardoned, let nothing remain but a deeper
humility in the heart, and a stricter regulation in our words, in our
actions, and in our sufferings.

“(4.)  The bearing men, and suffering evils in meekness and silence, is
the sum of a Christian life.

“God is the first object of our love: Its next office is, to bear the
defects of others.  And we should begin the practice of this amidst our
own household.

“We should chiefly exercise our love towards them who most shock either
our way of thinking, or our temper, or our knowledge, or the desire we
have, that others should be as virtuous as we wish to be ourselves.

“(5.)  God hardly gives his Spirit even to those whom he has
established in grace, if they do not pray for it on all occasions, not
only once, but many times.

“God does nothing but in answer to prayer; and even they who have been
converted to God without praying for it themselves, (which is exceeding
rare,) were not without the prayers of others.  Every new victory which
a soul gains is the effect of a new prayer.

“On every occasion of uneasiness, we should retire to prayer, that we
may give place to the grace and light of God and then form our
resolutions, without being in any pain about what success they may have.

In the greatest temptations, a single look to Christ, and the barely
pronouncing his name, suffices to overcome the wicked one, so it be done
with confidence and calmness of spirit.

God’s command to “pray without ceasing’ is founded on the necessity we
have of his grace to preserve the life of God in the soul, which can no
more subsist one moment without it, than the body can without air.

Whether we think of; or speak to, God, whether we act or suffer for
him, all is prayer, when we have no other object than his love, and the
desire of pleasing him.

“All that a Christian does, even in eating and sleeping, is prayer,
when it is done in simplicity, according to the order of God, without
either adding to or diminishing from it by his own choice.

“Prayer continues in the desire of the heart, though the understanding
be employed on outward things.

“In souls filled with love, the desire to please God is a continual
prayer.

“As the furious hate which the devil bears us is termed the roaring of
a lion, so our vehement love may be termed crying after God.

“God only requires of his adult children, that their hearts be truly
purified, and that they offer him continually the wishes and vows that
naturally spring from perfect love.  For these desires, being the
genuine fruits of love, are the most perfect prayers that can spring
from it.

(6.)  It is scarce conceivable how strait the way is wherein God leads
them that follow him; and how dependent on him we must be, unless we are
wanting in our faithfulness to him.

“It is hardly credible of how great consequence before God the smallest
things are; and what great inconveniences some times follow those which
appear to be light faults.

As a very little dust will disorder a clock, and the least sand will
obscure our sight, so the least grain of sin which is upon the heart
will hinder its right motion towards God.

“We ought to he in the church as the saints are in heaven, and in the
house as the holiest men are in the church; doing our work in the house
as we pray in the church; worshipping God from the ground of the heart.

“We should be continually labouring to cut off all the useless things
that surround us; and God usually retrenches the superfluities of our
souls in the same proportion as we do those of our bodies.

“The best means of resisting the devil is, to destroy whatever of the
world remains in us, in order to raise for God, upon its ruins, a
building all of love.  Then shall we begin, in this fleeting life, to
love God as we shall love him in eternity.

“We scarce conceive how easy it is to rob God of his due, in our
friendship with the most virtuous persons, until they are torn from us
by death.  But if this loss produce lasting sorrow, that is a clear
proof that we had before two treasures, between which we divided our
heart.

“(7.)  If, after having renounced all, we do not watch incessantly, and
beseech God to accompany our vigilance with his, we shall be again
entangled and overcome.

“As the most dangerous winds may enter at little openings, so the devil
never enters more dangerously than by little unobserved incidents, which
seem to be nothing, yet insensibly open the heart to great temptations.

“It is good to renew ourselves, from time to time, by closely examining
the state of our souls, as if we had never done it before; for nothing
tends more to the full assurance of faith, than to keep ourselves by
this means in humility, and the exercise of all good works.

“To continual watchfulness and prayer ought to be added continual
employment.  For grace flies a vacuum as well as nature; and the devil
fills whatever God does not fill.

“There is no faithfulness like that which ought to be between a guide
of souls and the person directed by him.  They ought continually to
regard each other in God, and closely to examine themselves, whether all
their thoughts are pure, and all their words directed with Christian
discretion.  Other affairs are only the things of men; but these are
peculiarly the things of God.

“(8.)  The words of St.  Paul, `No man can call Jesus Lord, but by the
Holy Ghost,’ show us the necessity of eyeing God in our good works, and
even in our minutest thoughts; knowing that none are pleasing to him,
but those which he forms in us and with us.  From hence we learn that we
cannot serve him, unless he use our tongue, hands, and heart, to do by
himself and his Spirit whatever he would have us to do.

“If we were not utterly impotent, our good works would be our own
property; whereas now they belong wholly to God, because they proceed
from him and his grace: While raising our works, and making them all
divine, he honours himself in us through them.

“One of the principal rules of religion is, to lose no occasion of
serving God.  And, since he is invisible to our eyes, we are to serve
him in our neighbour; which he receives as if done to himself in person,
standing visibly before us.

“God does not love men that are inconstant, nor good works that are
intermitted.  Nothing is pleasing to him, but what has a resemblance of
his own immutability.

“A constant attention to the work which God entrusts us with is a mark
of solid piety.

“Love fasts when it can, and as much as it can.  It leads to all the
ordinances of God, and employs itself in all the outward works whereof
it is capable.  It flies, as it were, like Elijah over the plain, to
find God upon his holy mountain.

“God is so great, that he communicates greatness to the least thing
that is done for his service.

“Happy are they who are sick, yea, or lose their life, for having done
a good work.

“God frequently conceals the part which his children have in the
conversion of other souls.  Yet one may boldly say, that person who long
groans before him for the conversion of another, whenever that soul is
converted to God, is one of the chief causes of it.

“Charity cannot be practised right, unless, First, we exercise it the
moment God gives the occasion; and, Secondly, retire the instant after
to offer it to God by humble thanksgiving.  And this for three reasons:
First, to render him what we have received from him.  The Second, to
avoid the dangerous temptation which springs from the very goodness of
these works.  And the Third, to unite ourselves to God, in whom the soul
expands itself in prayer, with all the graces we have received, and the
good works we have done, to draw from him new strength against the bad
effects which these very works may produce in us, if we do not make use
of the antidotes which God has ordained against these poisons.  The true
means to be filled anew with the riches of grace is thus to strip
ourselves of it; and without this it is extremely difficult not to grow
faint in the practice of good works.

“Good works do not receive their last perfection, till they, as it
were, lose themselves in God.  This is a kind of death to them,
resembling that of our bodies, which will not attain their highest life,
their immortality, till they lose themselves in the glory of our souls,
or rather of God, wherewith they shall be filled.  And it is only what
they had of earthly and mortal, which good works lose by this spiritual
death.

“Fire is the symbol of love; and the love of God is the principle and
the end of all our good works.  But truth surpasses figure; and the fire
of divine love has this advantage over material fire, that it can re-
ascend to its source, and raise thither with it all the good works which
it produces.  And by this means it prevents their being corrupted by
pride, vanity, or any evil mixture.  But this cannot be done otherwise
than by making these good works in a spiritual manner die in God, by a
deep gratitude, which plunges the soul in him as in an abyss, with all
that it is, and all the grace and works for which it is indebted to him;
a gratitude, whereby the soul seems to empty itself of them, that they
may return to their source, as rivers seem willing to empty themselves,
when they pour themselves with all their waters into the sea.

“When we have received any favour from God, we ought to retire, if not
into our closets, into our hearts, and say, `I come, Lord, to restore to
thee what thou hast given; and I freely relinquish it, to enter again
into my own nothingness.  For what is the most perfect creature in
heaven or earth in thy presence, but a void capable of being filled with
thee and by thee; as the air, which is void and dark, is capable of
being filled with the light of the sun, who withdraws it every day to
restore it the next, there being nothing in the air that either
appropriates this light or resists it?  O give me the same facility of
receiving and restoring thy grace and good works!  I say, +thine;+ for I
acknowledge the root from which they spring is in thee, and not in me.'”

26.  In the year 1764, upon a review of the whole subject, I wrote down
the sum of what I had observed in the following short propositions: —

“(1.)  There is such a thing as perfection; for it is again and again
mentioned in Scripture.

“(2.)  It is not so early as justification; for justified persons are
to `go on unto perfection.’  (Heb.  6:1.)

“(3.)  It is not so late as death; for St.  Paul speaks of living men
that were perfect.  (Phil.  3:15.)

“(4.)  It is not absolute.  Absolute perfection belongs not to man, nor
to angels, but to God alone.

“(5.)  It does not make a man infallible: None is infallible, while he
remains in the body.

“(6.)  Is it sinless?  It is not worth while to contend for a term.  It
is `salvation from sin.’

“(7.)  It is `perfect love.’  (1 John 4:18.)  This is the essence of
it; its properties, or inseparable fruits, are, rejoicing evermore,
praying without ceasing, and in everything giving thanks.  (1 Thess.
5:16, &c.)

“(8.)  It is improvable.  It is so far from lying in an indivisible
point, from being incapable of increase, that one perfected in love may
grow in grace far swifter than he did before.

“(9.)  It is amissible, capable of being lost; of which we have
numerous instances.  But we were not thoroughly convinced of this, till
five or six years ago.

“(10.)  It is constantly both preceded and followed by a gradual work.

“(11.)  But is it in itself instantaneous or not?  In examining this,
let us go on step by step.

“An instantaneous change has been wrought in some believers: None can
deny this.

“Since that change, they enjoy perfect love; they feel this, and this
alone; they `rejoice evermore, pray without ceasing, and in everything
give thanks.’  Now, this is all that I mean by perfection; therefore,
these are witnesses of the perfection which I preach.

“`But in some this change was not instantaneous.’  They did not
perceive the instant when it was wrought.  It is often difficult to
perceive the instant when a man dies; yet there is an instant in which
life ceases.  And if ever sin ceases, there must be a last moment of its
existence, and a first moment of our deliverance from it.

“`But if they have this love now, they will lose it.’  They may; but
they need not.  And whether they do or no, they have it now; they now
experience what we teach.  They now are all love; they now rejoice,
pray, and praise without ceasing.

“`However, sin is only suspended in them; it is not destroyed.’  Call
it which you please.  They are all love to-day; and they take no thought
for the morrow.

“`But this doctrine has been much abused.’  So has that of
justification by faith.  But that is no reason for giving up either this
or any other scriptural doctrine.  `When you wash your child,’ as one
speaks, `throw away the water; but do not throw away the child.’

“`But those who think they are saved from sin say they have no need of
the merits of Christ.’  They say just the contrary.  Their language is,
—

`Every moment, Lord, I want The merit of thy death!’

They never before had so deep, so unspeakable, a conviction of the need
of Christ in all his offices as they have now.

“Therefore, all our Preachers should make a point of preaching
perfection to believers constantly, strongly, and explicitly; and all
believers should mind this one thing, and continually agonize for it.”

27.  I have now done what I proposed.  I have given a plain and simple
account of the manner wherein I first received the doctrine of
perfection, and the sense wherein I received, and wherein I do receive,
and teach it to this day.  I have declared the whole and every part of
what I mean by that scriptural expression.  I have drawn the picture of
it at full length, without either disguise or covering.  And I would now
ask any impartial person, What is there so frightful herein?  Whence is
all this outcry, which, for these twenty years and upwards, has been
made throughout the kingdom; as if all Christianity were destroyed, and
all religion torn up by the roots?  Why is it, that the very name of
perfection has been cast out of the mouths of Christians; yea, exploded
and abhorred, as if it contained the most pernicious heresy?  Why have
the Preachers of it been hooted at, like mad dogs, even by men that fear
God; nay, and by some of their own children, some whom they, under God,
had begotten through the gospel?  What reason is there for this, or what
pretence?  Reason; sound reason, there is none.  It is impossible there
should.  But pretences there are, and those in great abundance.  Indeed,
there is ground to fear that, with some who treat us thus, it is mere
pretence; that it is no more than a copy of their countenance, from the
beginning to the end.  They wanted, they sought, occasion against me;
and here they found what they sought.  “This is Mr.  Wesley’s doctrine!
He preaches perfection!”  He does; yet this is not his doctrine any more
than it is yours, or any one’s else, that is a Minister of Christ.  For
it is His doctrine, peculiarly, emphatically His; it is the doctrine of
Jesus Christ.  Those are his words, not mine: _Esesthe oun teleioi,
hOsper ho PatEr HymOn ho en tois ouranois teleios esti,_ — “Ye shall
therefore be perfect, as your Father who is in heaven is perfect.”  And
who says, ye shall not; or, at least, not till your soul is separated
from the body?  It is the doctrine of St.  Paul, the doctrine of St.
James, of St.  Peter, and St.  John; and no otherwise Mr.  Wesley’s,
than as it is the doctrine of every one who preaches the pure and the
whole gospel.  I tell you, as plain as I can speak, where and when I
found this.  I found it in the oracles of God, in the Old and Now
Testament; when I read them with no other view or desire but to save my
own soul.  But whosesoever this doctrine is, I pray you, what harm is
there in it?  Look at it again; survey it on every side, and that with
the closest attention.  In one view, it is purity of intention,
dedicating all the life to God.  It is the giving God all our heart; it
is one desire and design ruling all our tempers.  It is the devoting,
not a part, but all our soul, body, and substance to God.  In another
view, it is all the mind which was in Christ, enabling us to walk as
Christ walked.  It is the circumcision of the heart from all filthiness,
all inward as well as outward pollution.  It is a renewal of the heart
in the whole image of God, the full likeness of Him that created it.  In
yet another, it is the loving God with all our heart, and our neighbour
as ourselves.  Now, take it in which of these views you please, (for
there is no material difference,) and this is the whole and sole
perfection, as a train of writings prove to a demonstration, which I
have believed and taught for these forty years, from the year 1725 to
the year 1765.

28.  Now let this perfection appear in its native form, and who can
speak one word against it?  Will any dare to speak against loving the
Lord our God with all our heart, and our neighbour as ourselves?
against a renewal of heart, not only in part, but in the whole image of
God?  Who is he that will open his mouth against being cleansed from all
pollution both of flesh and spirit; or against having all the mind that
was in Christ, and walking in all things as Christ walked?  What man,
who calls himself a Christian, has the hardiness to object to the
devoting, not a part, but all our soul, body, and substance to God?
What serious man would oppose the giving God all our heart, and the
having one design ruling all our tempers?  I say, again, let this
perfection appear in its own shape, and who will fight against it?  It
must be disguised before it can be opposed.  It must be covered with a
bear-skin first, or even the wild beasts of the people will scarce be
induced to worry it.  But whatever these do, let not the children of God
any longer fight against the image of God.  Let not the members of
Christ say anything against having the whole mind that was in Christ.
Let not those who are alive to God oppose the dedicating all our life to
Him.  Why should you who have his love shed abroad in your heart
withstand the giving him all your heart?  Does not all that is within
you cry out, “O who that loves can love enough?”  What pity that those
who desire and design to please him should have any other design or
desire!  much more, that they should dread, as a fatal delusion, yea,
abhor as an abomination to God, the having this one desire and design
ruling every temper!  Why should devout men be afraid of devoting all
their soul, body, and substance to God?  Why should those who love
Christ count it a damnable error, to think we may have all the mind that
was in him?  We allow, we contend, that we are justified freely through
the righteousness and the blood of Christ.  And why are you so hot
against us, because we expect likewise to be sanctified wholly through
his Spirit?  We look for no favour either from the open servants of sin,
or from those who have only the form of religion.  But how long will you
who worship God in spirit, who are “circumcised with the circumcision
not made with hands,” set our battle in array against those who seek a
entire circumcision of heart, who thirst to be cleansed “from all
filthiness of flesh and spirit,” and to “perfect holiness in the fear of
God?”  Are we your enemies, because we look for a full deliverance from
that “carnal mind which is enmity against God?”  Nay, we are your
brethren, your fellow-labourers in the vineyard of our Lord, your
companions in the kingdom and patience of Jesus.  Although this we
confess, (if we are fools therein, yet as fools bear with us,) we do
expect to love God with all our heart, and our neighbour as ourselves.
Yea, we do believe, that he will in this world so cleanse the thoughts
of our hearts, by the inspiration of his Holy Spirit, that we shall
perfectly love him, and worthily magnify his holy name.”

^____________________________^

^BRIEF THOUGHTS ON CHRISTIAN PERFECTION^

SOME thoughts occurred to my mind this morning concerning Christian
perfection, and the manner and time of receiving it, which I believe may
be useful to set down.

1.  By perfection I mean the humble, gentle, patient love of God, and
our neighbour, ruling our tempers, words, and actions.

I do not include an impossibility of falling from it, either in part or
in whole.  Therefore, I retract several expressions in our Hymns, which
partly express, partly imply, such an impossibility.

And I do not contend for the term +sinless,+ though I do not object
against it.

2.  As to the manner.  I believe this perfection is always wrought in
the soul by a simple act of faith; consequently, in an instant.

But I believe a gradual work, both preceding and following that
instant.

3.  As to the time.  I believe this instant generally is the instant of
death, the moment before the soul leaves the body.  But I believe it may
be ten, twenty, or forty years before.

I believe it is usually many years after justification; but that it may
be within five years or five months after it, I know no conclusive
argument to the contrary.

If it must be many years after justification, I would be glad to know
how many.  _Pretium quotus arroget annus?_ [This quotation from Horace
is thus translated by Boscawen: — “How many years give sanction to our
lines?”  — Edit.]

And how many days or months, or even years, can any one allow to be
between perfection and death?  How far from justification must it be;
and how near to death?

LONDON, Jan.  27, 1767.

[Edited by George Lyons for the Wesley Center for Applied Theology at
Northwest Nazarene College (Nampa, ID).]